V10.496 add market intel queue writer cli review gate

TODO_NEXT_STEPS.txt

@@ -4,6 +4,7 @@
 ================================================================================
 
 【已完成】
+   - V10.496 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Writer CLI Review 安全預覽 gate：只審核 writer preflight 後的 CLI review 草案，確認 script path、target table、preflight id、payload row count、candidate/dedupe keys 與 command argv；禁止 API 執行 CLI、禁止 `--execute` / `--apply-real-write` / `--approval-token` 進 payload，API 不讀 token、不寫檔、不開 DB、不寫 queue、不掛 scheduler。
    - V10.495 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Writer Preflight 安全預覽 gate：只審核 queue review 後的 writer preflight 草案，確認 target_table、write_mode、dedupe strategy、insert columns、payload rows 與候選 key 對齊；API 不開 DB、不執行 CLI、不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不寫 DB、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
    - V10.494 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Review 安全預覽 gate：只審核 candidate handoff 後的人工 queue review 草案，要求候選 key 對齊、review_state 停在 needs_review、allowed actions 限定人工確認/否決/延後、queue_write_status 維持 not_persisted；API 不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不寫 DB、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
    - V10.493 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Handoff Review 安全預覽 gate：只審核 parser review 後的候選交接包，確認 source/candidate key 對齊、queue policy 仍是 manual preview、候選數維持小批次、無 raw/secret/side-effect；API 不建立 queue、不寫 DB、不讀 artifact、不連外、不掛 scheduler。

config.py

@@ -350,7 +350,7 @@ YOUTUBE_API_KEY = os.getenv('YOUTUBE_API_KEY', '')
 # ==========================================
 # 系統版本與路徑
 # ==========================================
-SYSTEM_VERSION = "V10.495"
+SYSTEM_VERSION = "V10.496"
 LOG_FILE_PATH = os.path.join(BASE_DIR, 'logs/system.log')
 public_url = PUBLIC_URL  # 用於模板顯示
 

docs/adr/ADR-035-cross-platform-market-campaign-intelligence.md

@@ -167,6 +167,7 @@ EwoooC 目前已有 MOMO EDM / 節慶活動資料、`promo_products`、PChome
 - 2026-05-31 追加 MCP fetch candidate handoff review gate：`services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_handoff_review` 與 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_handoff_review` 在 parser review 通過後審核候選交接包，檢查 source/candidate key 對齊、queue policy 是否仍是 `manual_candidate_review` / `preview_only`、小批次候選上限、操作員無寫入/無連外/無排程確認、raw HTML/secret 外洩與 side-effect flags；API/UI 不建立 queue、不讀 artifact、不寫 DB、不掛 scheduler，只放行到人工 candidate queue review。
 - 2026-05-31 追加 MCP fetch candidate queue review gate：`services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review` 與 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review` 在 handoff review 通過後審核人工 queue review 草案，檢查候選 key 對齊、`review_state=needs_review`、allowed actions 人工限定、`queue_write_status=not_persisted`、操作員無寫入/無連外/無排程確認、raw HTML/secret 外洩與 side-effect flags；API/UI 不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不讀 artifact、不寫 DB、不掛 scheduler，只放行到 writer preflight。
 - 2026-05-31 追加 MCP fetch candidate queue writer preflight gate：`services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight` 與 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight` 在 queue review 通過後審核 writer preflight 草案，檢查 `target_table=market_alert_review_queue`、`write_mode=cli_only_later`、dedupe strategy、insert columns、payload rows、候選 key 對齊、小批次上限、操作員無寫入/無連外/無 CLI/無排程確認、raw HTML/secret 外洩與 side-effect flags；API/UI 不開 DB、不執行 CLI、不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不寫 DB、不掛 scheduler，只放行到 CLI writer review。
+- 2026-05-31 追加 MCP fetch candidate queue writer CLI review gate：`services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review` 與 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review` 在 writer preflight 通過後審核 CLI review 草案，檢查 script path、target table、preflight id、payload row count、candidate/dedupe keys、`--sample-json`、`--read-only-preflight` 與 forbidden flags；API/UI 不執行 CLI、不讀 approval token、不寫檔、不開 DB、不寫 queue、不掛 scheduler，只放行到 operator run package review。
 - 2026-05-18 追加 scheduler attach plan preview：`services.market_intel.scheduler_plan` 與 `/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan` 描述未來 `campaign_discovery_daily`、`campaign_product_probe`、`product_match_review_seed` 三個 job 的 cadence、gate、fallback 與安全邊界。此階段不註冊 scheduler job、不啟動 crawler、不連外、不寫 DB；排程掛載必須等 migration、seed、MCP fetch gate、manual sample 與人工批准全過。
 - 2026-05-18 追加 match review plan preview：`services.market_intel.match_review_plan` 與 `/api/market_intel/match_review_plan` 定義商品比對訊號、分數門檻、`needs_review → confirmed/rejected` HITL 流程與安全邊界。此階段不建立 review queue、不自動 confirmed、不寫 `market_product_matches`、不呼叫 MCP；價格只能作為輔助訊號，不能單獨決定同品比對。
 - 2026-05-18 追加 opportunity plan preview：`services.market_intel.opportunity_plan` 與 `/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan` 定義競品低價威脅、促銷缺口、深折重疊、活動即將結束四類規則與分級策略。此階段不建立 opportunity queue、不派送 Telegram、不產生 AI 摘要、不寫 DB；高風險項必須先有 confirmed match 與 DB evidence 才能升級。

docs/memory/code_modularization_inventory_20260430.md

@@ -45,6 +45,7 @@
 - 2026-05-31 追記：同步市場情報 MCP fetch candidate queue review gate 後的 `services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py` 行數；本次新增邏輯維持在獨立 `services/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review.py`，route 延續 `routes/market_intel_mcp_run_routes.py` extension。
 - 2026-05-31 追記：同步市場情報 MCP fetch candidate queue writer preflight gate 後的 `services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py` 行數；本次新增邏輯維持在獨立 `services/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight.py`，route 延續 `routes/market_intel_mcp_run_routes.py` extension。
 - 2026-05-31 追記：`services/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight.py` 目前 628 行，略過 600 行提醒門檻；暫不拆分的理由是 gate 條件、sample payload 與 side-effect blocklist 需留在單一 preview module 便於審核，下一個 writer CLI review gate 若共用相同常數再抽 `mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_policy.py`。
+- 2026-05-31 追記：同步市場情報 MCP fetch candidate queue writer CLI review gate 後的 `services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py` 行數；本次新增 `services/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review.py` 為 591 行，仍低於 600 行提醒門檻。
 - 2026-05-24 追記：同步背景 Code Review 111 fallback 保護合併後的 `services/code_review_pipeline_service.py` 行數；此處只更新 inventory，不變更 Code Review 行為。
 - 2026-05-21 追記：同步 PChome/LUDEYA 商品線名稱漂移比對更新後的 `services/marketplace_product_matcher.py` 行數；此處只更新 inventory，不變更模組化決策。
 - 2026-05-21 追記：同步 MAC/Yuskin/AHC 名稱漂移與 bundle equivalent matcher 更新後的 `services/marketplace_product_matcher.py` 行數；此處只更新 inventory，不變更模組化決策。
@@ -97,7 +98,7 @@
 | 805 | `routes/bot_api_routes.py` | P2 Bot API Blueprint | route glue / bot action service |
 | 1319 | `routes/market_intel_review_report_routes.py` | P2 market intel review report Blueprint | review report route glue / export payload / phase handoff orchestration |
 | 917 | `routes/market_intel_routes.py` | P2 market intel Blueprint | page route / API route glue / MCP gate route registration helper |
-| 1219 | `services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py` | P2 market intel deployment readiness | preflight gates / readiness payload / route contract helpers |
+| 1260 | `services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py` | P2 market intel deployment readiness | preflight gates / readiness payload / route contract helpers |
 | 846 | `services/market_intel/candidate_queue_review_ai_summary_persistence_telegram_dispatch_report_catalog_record_run_receipt.py` | P2 market intel review receipt pipeline | AI summary / persistence / Telegram dispatch / report catalog run receipt orchestration |
 
 ## 市場情報開發前置禁區

docs/memory/current_execution_queue_20260524.md

@@ -91,6 +91,7 @@
 - 2026-05-31 起，`V10.493` 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Handoff Review gate：在 parser review 通過後只審核候選交接包，要求 source/candidate key 完全對齊、queue policy 維持 manual preview、小批次上限與操作員無寫入/無連外/無排程確認；仍不建立 queue、不寫 DB、不讀 artifact、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
 - 2026-05-31 起，`V10.494` 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Review gate：在 handoff review 通過後只審核人工 queue review 草案，要求候選 key 完全對齊、review_state 只停在 `needs_review`、allowed actions 限人工操作、queue_write_status 維持 `not_persisted`；仍不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不寫 DB、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
 - 2026-05-31 起，`V10.495` 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Writer Preflight gate：在 queue review 通過後只審核 writer preflight 草案，要求 target table、write mode、dedupe strategy、insert columns、payload rows 與候選 key 完全對齊；仍不開 DB、不執行 CLI、不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不寫 DB、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
+- 2026-05-31 起，`V10.496` 新增市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Writer CLI Review gate：在 writer preflight 通過後只審核 CLI review 草案，要求 script path、target table、preflight id、row count、candidate/dedupe keys 與 read-only command argv 對齊；仍不執行 CLI、不讀 approval token、不寫檔、不開 DB、不寫 queue、不掛 scheduler。
 
 ## 3. 12 Agent 決策信封整合
 

docs/memory/history_logs.md

@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@
 ## 📅 詳細更新日誌 (考古存檔)
 
 ### 2026-05-24：PChome 近門檻身份回收第二輪
+- **V10.496 市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Writer CLI Review gate**: 新增 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review` 與 UI preview，只審核 writer preflight 後的 CLI review 草案；要求 script path、target table、preflight id、payload row count、candidate/dedupe keys 與 command argv 完全對齊，並禁止 `--execute`、`--apply-real-write`、`--approval-token` 進 API payload，且 API 不執行 CLI、不讀 token、不寫檔、不開 DB、不寫 queue、不掛 scheduler。
 - **V10.495 市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Writer Preflight gate**: 新增 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight` 與 UI preview，只審核 queue review 後的 writer preflight 草案；要求 `target_table=market_alert_review_queue`、`write_mode=cli_only_later`、dedupe strategy、insert columns、payload rows 與候選 key 完全對齊，且 API 不開 DB、不執行 CLI、不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不寫 DB、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
 - **V10.494 市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Queue Review gate**: 新增 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review` 與 UI preview，只審核 candidate handoff 後的人工 queue review 草案；要求候選 key 完全對齊、`review_state=needs_review`、allowed actions 限人工確認/否決/延後、`queue_write_status=not_persisted`，且 API 不建立 queue、不更新 review_state、不寫 DB、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
 - **V10.493 市場情報 MCP Fetch Candidate Handoff Review gate**: 新增 `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_handoff_review` 與 UI preview，只審核 parser review 後的候選交接包；要求 source/candidate key 完全對齊、queue policy 維持 `manual_candidate_review` / `preview_only`、候選數維持小批次，且 API 不建立 queue、不寫 DB、不讀 artifact、不連外、不掛 scheduler。

routes/market_intel_mcp_run_routes.py

@@ -28,6 +28,9 @@ from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review import (
 from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight import (
     build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_preview,
 )
+from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review import (
+    build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview,
+)
 
 
 @market_intel_bp.route("/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_run_package", methods=["GET", "POST"])
@@ -298,3 +301,49 @@ def market_intel_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight():
             phase=service.phase,
         )
     )
+
+
+@market_intel_bp.route(
+    "/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review",
+    methods=["GET", "POST"],
+)
+@login_required
+def market_intel_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review():
+    writer_preflight_package = {}
+    writer_preflight_result = None
+    writer_cli_review = None
+    if request.method == "POST":
+        payload = request.get_json(silent=True) or {}
+        package = (
+            payload.get("writer_cli_review_package")
+            or payload.get("candidate_queue_writer_cli_review")
+            or payload.get("writer_cli_review")
+            or payload
+        )
+        writer_preflight_package = (
+            package.get("writer_preflight_package")
+            or package.get("candidate_queue_writer_preflight")
+            or package.get("writer_preflight")
+            or package.get("preflight_package")
+            or {}
+        )
+        writer_preflight_result = (
+            package.get("writer_preflight_result")
+            or package.get("mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight")
+        )
+        writer_cli_review = (
+            package.get("writer_cli_review")
+            or package.get("candidate_queue_writer_cli_review")
+            or package.get("cli_review")
+            or package.get("review_payload")
+        )
+
+    service = MarketIntelService()
+    return jsonify(
+        build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview(
+            writer_preflight_package=writer_preflight_package,
+            writer_preflight_result=writer_preflight_result,
+            writer_cli_review=writer_cli_review,
+            phase=service.phase,
+        )
+    )

services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py

@@ -84,6 +84,9 @@ from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review import (
 from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight import (
     build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_preview,
 )
+from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review import (
+    build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview,
+)
 from services.market_intel.mcp_manual_fetch_handoff import (
     build_mcp_manual_fetch_handoff_preview,
 )
@@ -221,6 +224,11 @@ PRODUCTION_SMOKE_TARGETS = (
     + ("/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight",)
     + PRODUCTION_SMOKE_TARGETS[-1:]
 )
+PRODUCTION_SMOKE_TARGETS = (
+    PRODUCTION_SMOKE_TARGETS[:-1]
+    + ("/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review",)
+    + PRODUCTION_SMOKE_TARGETS[-1:]
+)
 def _run_review_preview_safe(payload, mode):
     return bool(payload["mode"] == mode and all(not payload.get(key) for key in BLOCKED_RUN_REVIEW_KEYS))
 def build_deployment_readiness_preview(*, service, market_intel_tables, schema_smoke_builder):
@@ -275,6 +283,11 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(*, service, market_intel_tables, schema_s
             phase=service.phase,
         )
     )
+    mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review = (
+        build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview(
+            phase=service.phase,
+        )
+    )
     scheduler_plan = service.build_scheduler_plan()
     manual_sample_plan = service.build_manual_sample_plan()
     manual_sample_acceptance = service.build_manual_sample_acceptance()
@@ -822,6 +835,33 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(*, service, market_intel_tables, schema_s
             and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight["file_written"]
             and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight["scheduler_attached"]
         ),
+        "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview_safe": bool(
+            mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["mode"]
+            == "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview"
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["payload_persisted"]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["cli_review_persisted"]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review[
+                "package_artifact_created"
+            ]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["api_writes_file"]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["api_executes_cli"]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review[
+                "api_reads_approval_token"
+            ]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review[
+                "api_opens_database_connection"
+            ]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["api_writes_database"]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review[
+                "api_uses_external_network"
+            ]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review[
+                "database_write_executed"
+            ]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["cli_executed"]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["file_written"]
+            and not mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review["scheduler_attached"]
+        ),
         "candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke_planned_safe": bool(
             candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke["mode"]
             == "candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke_planned"
@@ -1142,6 +1182,7 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(*, service, market_intel_tables, schema_s
         "mcp_fetch_candidate_handoff_review": mcp_fetch_candidate_handoff_review,
         "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review": mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review,
         "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight": mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight,
+        "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review": mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review,
         "scheduler_plan": scheduler_plan,
         "manual_sample_plan": manual_sample_plan,
         "manual_sample_acceptance": manual_sample_acceptance,

services/market_intel/mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review.py

@@ -0,0 +1,591 @@
+"""市場情報 MCP fetch candidate queue writer CLI review preview。
+
+本模組只審核 writer preflight 後的 CLI review 草案；API/UI 不執行 CLI、
+不讀 approval token、不開 DB、不寫 queue、不掛 scheduler。
+"""
+
+from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight import (
+    TARGET_TABLE,
+    build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_preview,
+)
+
+
+SCRIPT_PATH = "scripts/market_intel_candidate_queue_writer.py"
+MAX_CLI_REVIEW_ITEMS = 80
+SAFE_REVIEW_MODES = {"candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview"}
+SAFE_COMMAND_MODES = {"manual_shell_review_only"}
+REQUIRED_SAFE_FLAGS = ("--sample-json", "--read-only-preflight")
+FORBIDDEN_COMMAND_FLAGS = (
+    "--apply-real-write",
+    "--approval-token",
+    "--execute",
+)
+
+FORBIDDEN_SECRET_KEYS = (
+    "approval_token",
+    "approval-token",
+    "api_key",
+    "authorization",
+    "bearer",
+    "client_secret",
+    "cookie",
+    "password",
+    "secret",
+    "session_cookie",
+    "token",
+)
+
+SAFE_SECRET_METADATA_KEYS = {
+    "approval_token_shell_only",
+    "operator_confirmed_no_approval_token_in_payload",
+    "operator_confirmed_no_secret_payload",
+}
+
+FORBIDDEN_RAW_PAYLOAD_KEYS = (
+    "body_html",
+    "document_html",
+    "html",
+    "page_html",
+    "raw_body",
+    "raw_html",
+    "raw_snapshot",
+    "response_body",
+)
+
+_BLOCKED_SIDE_EFFECT_KEYS = (
+    "allow_api_execution",
+    "allow_cli_execution",
+    "allow_database_write",
+    "allow_external_network_in_api",
+    "allow_scheduler_attach",
+    "api_executed_cli",
+    "api_executes_cli",
+    "api_opens_database_connection",
+    "api_reads_approval_token",
+    "api_uses_external_network",
+    "api_writes_database",
+    "api_writes_file",
+    "apply_real_write",
+    "attach_scheduler",
+    "candidate_queue_created",
+    "candidate_queue_persisted",
+    "candidate_review_state_updated",
+    "cli_executed",
+    "command_executed",
+    "database_commit_executed",
+    "database_connection_opened",
+    "database_session_created",
+    "database_write_executed",
+    "execute_requested",
+    "external_network_executed",
+    "file_written",
+    "network_request_allowed",
+    "package_artifact_created",
+    "payload_persisted",
+    "ready_for_api_database_write",
+    "ready_for_real_write",
+    "review_state_update_executed",
+    "scheduler_attached",
+    "write_database",
+    "writes_executed",
+    "would_write_database",
+)
+
+
+def _as_dict(value):
+    return value if isinstance(value, dict) else {}
+
+
+def _as_list(value):
+    if value is None:
+        return []
+    if isinstance(value, (list, tuple, set)):
+        return list(value)
+    return [value]
+
+
+def _safe_int(value):
+    try:
+        return int(value or 0)
+    except (TypeError, ValueError):
+        return 0
+
+
+def _safe_text(value, limit=500):
+    if value is None:
+        return None
+    text = str(value).strip()
+    return text[:limit] if text else None
+
+
+def _contains_forbidden_key(value, forbidden_keys, *, safe_keys=None):
+    safe_keys = safe_keys or set()
+    if isinstance(value, dict):
+        for key, nested in value.items():
+            normalized_key = str(key).lower()
+            if normalized_key in safe_keys and isinstance(nested, bool):
+                continue
+            if any(forbidden_key in normalized_key for forbidden_key in forbidden_keys):
+                return True
+            if _contains_forbidden_key(nested, forbidden_keys, safe_keys=safe_keys):
+                return True
+    elif isinstance(value, list):
+        return any(
+            _contains_forbidden_key(item, forbidden_keys, safe_keys=safe_keys)
+            for item in value
+        )
+    return False
+
+
+def _blocked_side_effects(payload):
+    found = []
+
+    def visit(value, path):
+        if isinstance(value, dict):
+            for key, item in value.items():
+                normalized_key = str(key).lower()
+                key_path = f"{path}.{key}" if path else key
+                if normalized_key in _BLOCKED_SIDE_EFFECT_KEYS and bool(item):
+                    found.append(key_path)
+                visit(item, key_path)
+        elif isinstance(value, list):
+            for index, item in enumerate(value):
+                visit(item, f"{path}[{index}]")
+
+    visit(payload, "")
+    return found
+
+
+def _preflight_from_inputs(preflight_package, preflight_result, phase):
+    if isinstance(preflight_result, dict) and preflight_result:
+        return preflight_result
+
+    preflight_package = _as_dict(preflight_package)
+    return build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_preview(
+        queue_review_package=(
+            preflight_package.get("queue_review_package")
+            or preflight_package.get("candidate_queue_review")
+            or preflight_package.get("queue_review")
+        ),
+        queue_review_result=(
+            preflight_package.get("queue_review_result")
+            or preflight_package.get("mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_review")
+        ),
+        writer_preflight=(
+            preflight_package.get("writer_preflight")
+            or preflight_package.get("candidate_queue_writer_preflight")
+            or preflight_package.get("preflight")
+        ),
+        phase=phase,
+    )
+
+
+def _preflight_summary(preflight):
+    preflight = _as_dict(preflight)
+    writer_summary = _as_dict(preflight.get("writer_preflight_summary"))
+    rows = _as_list(writer_summary.get("payload_rows"))
+    side_effects_clear = bool(
+        not preflight.get("network_request_allowed")
+        and not preflight.get("api_executes_cli")
+        and not preflight.get("api_opens_database_connection")
+        and not preflight.get("api_writes_database")
+        and not preflight.get("api_uses_external_network")
+        and not preflight.get("database_write_executed")
+        and not preflight.get("cli_executed")
+        and not preflight.get("file_written")
+        and not preflight.get("scheduler_attached")
+        and not preflight.get("candidate_queue_created")
+        and not preflight.get("candidate_queue_persisted")
+        and not preflight.get("candidate_review_state_updated")
+    )
+    return {
+        "mode": preflight.get("mode"),
+        "accepted": bool(
+            preflight.get("mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_accepted")
+        ),
+        "ready_for_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review": bool(
+            preflight.get("ready_for_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review")
+        ),
+        "target_table": writer_summary.get("target_table"),
+        "preflight_id": writer_summary.get("preflight_id"),
+        "payload_row_count": _safe_int(writer_summary.get("payload_row_count")),
+        "campaign_candidate_count": _safe_int(
+            writer_summary.get("campaign_candidate_count")
+        ),
+        "product_candidate_count": _safe_int(
+            writer_summary.get("product_candidate_count")
+        ),
+        "candidate_keys": sorted(
+            row.get("candidate_key") for row in rows if row.get("candidate_key")
+        ),
+        "dedupe_keys": sorted(row.get("dedupe_key") for row in rows if row.get("dedupe_key")),
+        "side_effects_clear": side_effects_clear,
+        "blocked_reasons": preflight.get("blocked_reasons", []),
+    }
+
+
+def _sample_cli_review_package():
+    preflight_preview = build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_preview()
+    preflight_package = preflight_preview["sample_writer_preflight_package"]
+    preflight_result = build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_preview(
+        queue_review_package=preflight_package["queue_review_package"],
+        queue_review_result=preflight_package["queue_review_result"],
+        writer_preflight=preflight_package["writer_preflight"],
+    )
+    preflight = _preflight_summary(preflight_result)
+    return {
+        "writer_preflight_package": preflight_package,
+        "writer_preflight_result": preflight_result,
+        "writer_cli_review": {
+            "review_id": "market-intel-candidate-writer-cli-review-sample",
+            "review_mode": "candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview",
+            "command_mode": "manual_shell_review_only",
+            "script_path": SCRIPT_PATH,
+            "target_table": TARGET_TABLE,
+            "preflight_id": preflight["preflight_id"],
+            "expected_payload_row_count": preflight["payload_row_count"],
+            "expected_candidate_keys": preflight["candidate_keys"],
+            "expected_dedupe_keys": preflight["dedupe_keys"],
+            "command_argv_preview": [
+                "python3",
+                SCRIPT_PATH,
+                "--sample-json",
+                "<operator-reviewed-json>",
+                "--read-only-preflight",
+            ],
+            "operator_confirmed_no_api_cli_execution": True,
+            "operator_confirmed_no_database_write": True,
+            "operator_confirmed_no_external_network": True,
+            "operator_confirmed_no_scheduler_attach": True,
+            "operator_confirmed_no_persistence": True,
+            "operator_confirmed_no_approval_token_in_payload": True,
+            "operator_confirmed_no_secret_payload": True,
+            "dry_run_first_required": True,
+            "approval_token_shell_only": True,
+            "api_execution_allowed": False,
+            "real_write_allowed": False,
+        },
+    }
+
+
+def _cli_review_summary(cli_review):
+    cli_review = _as_dict(cli_review)
+    command_argv = [
+        _safe_text(item, 200) for item in _as_list(cli_review.get("command_argv_preview"))
+    ]
+    command_argv = [item for item in command_argv if item]
+    candidate_keys = sorted(
+        key for key in _as_list(cli_review.get("expected_candidate_keys")) if key
+    )
+    dedupe_keys = sorted(
+        key for key in _as_list(cli_review.get("expected_dedupe_keys")) if key
+    )
+    operator_boundaries_confirmed = bool(
+        cli_review.get("operator_confirmed_no_api_cli_execution")
+        and cli_review.get("operator_confirmed_no_database_write")
+        and cli_review.get("operator_confirmed_no_external_network")
+        and cli_review.get("operator_confirmed_no_scheduler_attach")
+        and cli_review.get("operator_confirmed_no_persistence")
+        and cli_review.get("operator_confirmed_no_approval_token_in_payload")
+        and cli_review.get("operator_confirmed_no_secret_payload")
+    )
+    return {
+        "provided_keys": sorted(cli_review.keys()),
+        "review_id": _safe_text(cli_review.get("review_id"), 160),
+        "review_mode": _safe_text(cli_review.get("review_mode"), 120),
+        "command_mode": _safe_text(cli_review.get("command_mode"), 120),
+        "script_path": _safe_text(cli_review.get("script_path"), 240),
+        "target_table": _safe_text(cli_review.get("target_table"), 160),
+        "preflight_id": _safe_text(cli_review.get("preflight_id"), 160),
+        "expected_payload_row_count": _safe_int(
+            cli_review.get("expected_payload_row_count")
+        ),
+        "expected_candidate_keys": candidate_keys,
+        "expected_dedupe_keys": dedupe_keys,
+        "command_argv_preview": command_argv,
+        "required_safe_flags_present": all(
+            flag in command_argv for flag in REQUIRED_SAFE_FLAGS
+        ),
+        "forbidden_command_flags_absent": not any(
+            flag in command_argv for flag in FORBIDDEN_COMMAND_FLAGS
+        ),
+        "command_invokes_expected_script": bool(
+            SCRIPT_PATH in command_argv and command_argv[:1] in (["python"], ["python3"])
+        ),
+        "operator_boundaries_confirmed": operator_boundaries_confirmed,
+        "dry_run_first_required": bool(cli_review.get("dry_run_first_required")),
+        "approval_token_shell_only": bool(cli_review.get("approval_token_shell_only")),
+        "api_execution_allowed": bool(cli_review.get("api_execution_allowed")),
+        "real_write_allowed": bool(cli_review.get("real_write_allowed")),
+        "candidate_keys_unique": bool(
+            candidate_keys and len(set(candidate_keys)) == len(candidate_keys)
+        ),
+        "dedupe_keys_unique": bool(
+            dedupe_keys and len(set(dedupe_keys)) == len(dedupe_keys)
+        ),
+        "raw_payload_submitted_to_api": _contains_forbidden_key(
+            cli_review,
+            FORBIDDEN_RAW_PAYLOAD_KEYS,
+        ),
+        "secret_or_token_submitted_to_api": _contains_forbidden_key(
+            cli_review,
+            FORBIDDEN_SECRET_KEYS,
+            safe_keys=SAFE_SECRET_METADATA_KEYS,
+        ),
+        "blocked_side_effects": _blocked_side_effects(cli_review),
+    }
+
+
+def _review_gates(
+    *,
+    preflight_received,
+    cli_review_received,
+    cli_review_valid_object,
+    preflight,
+    cli_review,
+):
+    preflight_candidate_keys = set(preflight["candidate_keys"])
+    review_candidate_keys = set(cli_review["expected_candidate_keys"])
+    preflight_dedupe_keys = set(preflight["dedupe_keys"])
+    review_dedupe_keys = set(cli_review["expected_dedupe_keys"])
+    return [
+        {
+            "key": "writer_preflight_payload_or_result_received",
+            "label": "已提供 writer preflight package 或已審核結果",
+            "passed": preflight_received,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_preflight_accepted",
+            "label": "writer preflight gate 必須已通過",
+            "passed": preflight["accepted"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_preflight_ready_for_cli_review",
+            "label": "writer preflight 只放行到 CLI review",
+            "passed": preflight["ready_for_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_preflight_side_effect_free",
+            "label": "writer preflight 未顯示 API 執行、寫 DB 或掛 scheduler",
+            "passed": preflight["side_effects_clear"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_review_payload_received",
+            "label": "已提供 writer CLI review 草案",
+            "passed": cli_review_received,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_review_valid_object",
+            "label": "writer CLI review payload 必須是 JSON object",
+            "passed": cli_review_valid_object,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_review_identity_recorded",
+            "label": "writer CLI review 必須記錄 review_id",
+            "passed": bool(cli_review["review_id"]),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_review_mode_preview_only",
+            "label": "writer CLI review 必須維持 preview mode",
+            "passed": cli_review["review_mode"] in SAFE_REVIEW_MODES,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_command_mode_manual_shell_only",
+            "label": "command mode 必須是 manual_shell_review_only",
+            "passed": cli_review["command_mode"] in SAFE_COMMAND_MODES,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_script_path_safe",
+            "label": "script path 必須是候選 queue writer CLI",
+            "passed": cli_review["script_path"] == SCRIPT_PATH,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_target_table_safe",
+            "label": "target table 必須是 market_alert_review_queue",
+            "passed": cli_review["target_table"] == TARGET_TABLE,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_preflight_id_matches",
+            "label": "CLI review preflight_id 必須對齊 writer preflight",
+            "passed": bool(
+                cli_review["preflight_id"]
+                and cli_review["preflight_id"] == preflight["preflight_id"]
+            ),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_payload_count_matches_preflight",
+            "label": "CLI review row count 必須對齊 writer preflight",
+            "passed": bool(
+                0 < cli_review["expected_payload_row_count"] <= MAX_CLI_REVIEW_ITEMS
+                and cli_review["expected_payload_row_count"]
+                == preflight["payload_row_count"]
+            ),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_candidate_keys_match_preflight",
+            "label": "CLI review candidate keys 必須完全對齊 writer preflight",
+            "passed": bool(
+                preflight_candidate_keys
+                and review_candidate_keys == preflight_candidate_keys
+                and cli_review["candidate_keys_unique"]
+            ),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_dedupe_keys_match_preflight",
+            "label": "CLI review dedupe keys 必須完全對齊 writer preflight",
+            "passed": bool(
+                preflight_dedupe_keys
+                and review_dedupe_keys == preflight_dedupe_keys
+                and cli_review["dedupe_keys_unique"]
+            ),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_command_invokes_expected_script",
+            "label": "command argv 必須只預覽候選 queue writer script",
+            "passed": cli_review["command_invokes_expected_script"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_required_safe_flags_present",
+            "label": "command argv 必須包含 sample-json 與 read-only preflight",
+            "passed": cli_review["required_safe_flags_present"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_forbidden_write_flags_absent",
+            "label": "command argv 不得包含 execute/apply/approval-token",
+            "passed": cli_review["forbidden_command_flags_absent"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_operator_boundaries_confirmed",
+            "label": "操作員確認 API 不執行 CLI、不讀 token、不寫 DB、不保存、不掛排程",
+            "passed": cli_review["operator_boundaries_confirmed"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_dry_run_first_required",
+            "label": "正式流程必須先 dry-run / read-only preflight",
+            "passed": cli_review["dry_run_first_required"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_approval_token_shell_only",
+            "label": "approval token 只能在 shell 提供，不得進 API payload",
+            "passed": cli_review["approval_token_shell_only"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_no_api_execution_or_real_write",
+            "label": "API review payload 不得允許 CLI 執行或 real write",
+            "passed": bool(
+                not cli_review["api_execution_allowed"]
+                and not cli_review["real_write_allowed"]
+            ),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_no_raw_payload",
+            "label": "writer CLI review payload 不得回貼 raw HTML/body/snapshot",
+            "passed": not cli_review["raw_payload_submitted_to_api"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_no_secret_or_token_key",
+            "label": "writer CLI review payload 不得包含 secret、cookie、password 或 token key",
+            "passed": not cli_review["secret_or_token_submitted_to_api"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_side_effect_free",
+            "label": "writer CLI review payload 不得要求 API 執行、寫檔、寫 DB 或掛 scheduler",
+            "passed": not cli_review["blocked_side_effects"],
+        },
+    ]
+
+
+def build_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview(
+    *,
+    writer_preflight_package=None,
+    writer_preflight_result=None,
+    writer_cli_review=None,
+    phase=None,
+):
+    """建立 fetch candidate queue writer CLI review；不執行 CLI 或寫入。"""
+    writer_preflight_package = _as_dict(writer_preflight_package)
+    preflight_result_received = bool(
+        isinstance(writer_preflight_result, dict) and writer_preflight_result
+    )
+    cli_review_valid_object = (
+        isinstance(writer_cli_review, dict) if writer_cli_review is not None else True
+    )
+    cli_review_payload = _as_dict(writer_cli_review)
+    preflight_data = _preflight_from_inputs(
+        writer_preflight_package,
+        writer_preflight_result,
+        phase,
+    )
+    preflight_received = bool(
+        writer_preflight_package or preflight_result_received
+    )
+    payload_received = bool(
+        preflight_received or cli_review_payload or writer_cli_review is not None
+    )
+    cli_review_received = bool(cli_review_payload)
+    preflight = _preflight_summary(preflight_data)
+    cli_review = _cli_review_summary(cli_review_payload)
+    gates = _review_gates(
+        preflight_received=preflight_received,
+        cli_review_received=cli_review_received,
+        cli_review_valid_object=cli_review_valid_object,
+        preflight=preflight,
+        cli_review=cli_review,
+    )
+    blocked_reasons = [gate["key"] for gate in gates if not gate["passed"]]
+    accepted = bool(payload_received and not blocked_reasons)
+
+    return {
+        "mode": (
+            "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review"
+            if payload_received
+            else "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_preview"
+        ),
+        "phase": phase,
+        "writer_cli_review_payload_received": payload_received,
+        "writer_preflight_received": preflight_received,
+        "writer_cli_review_received": cli_review_received,
+        "writer_cli_review_valid_object": cli_review_valid_object,
+        "writer_preflight_accepted": preflight["accepted"],
+        "mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_accepted": accepted,
+        "candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_ready": accepted,
+        "ready_for_candidate_queue_writer_run_package_review": accepted,
+        "ready_for_api_database_write": False,
+        "ready_for_real_write": False,
+        "ready_for_scheduler_attach": False,
+        "network_request_allowed": False,
+        "api_executes_cli": False,
+        "api_reads_approval_token": False,
+        "api_opens_database_connection": False,
+        "api_writes_database": False,
+        "api_uses_external_network": False,
+        "cli_executed": False,
+        "candidate_queue_created": False,
+        "candidate_queue_persisted": False,
+        "candidate_review_state_updated": False,
+        "payload_row_count": cli_review["expected_payload_row_count"],
+        "gate_count": len(gates),
+        "passed_gate_count": sum(1 for gate in gates if gate["passed"]),
+        "blocked_reasons": blocked_reasons,
+        "gates": gates,
+        "writer_preflight_summary": preflight,
+        "writer_cli_review_summary": cli_review,
+        "sample_writer_cli_review_package": _sample_cli_review_package(),
+        "next_operator_steps": [
+            "CLI review 通過後，只代表可整理 operator run package，不代表可執行 CLI",
+            "真正 --execute、--apply-real-write 與 approval token 必須留在人工 shell gate",
+            "API/UI 仍不得讀 token、不得執行 CLI、不得開 DB、不得寫 queue",
+        ],
+        "payload_persisted": False,
+        "cli_review_persisted": False,
+        "package_artifact_created": False,
+        "api_writes_file": False,
+        "database_session_created": False,
+        "database_commit_executed": False,
+        "database_write_executed": False,
+        "external_network_executed": False,
+        "file_written": False,
+        "writes_executed": False,
+        "would_write_database": False,
+        "scheduler_attached": False,
+    }

services/market_intel/phase.py

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 """市場情報 rollout phase 單一來源。"""
 
-MARKET_INTEL_PHASE = "phase_128_market_intel_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight"
+MARKET_INTEL_PHASE = "phase_129_market_intel_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review"

templates/market_intel/disabled.html

@@ -864,6 +864,32 @@
         </div>
     </div>
 
+    <div class="market-intel-panel" data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review>
+        <div class="market-intel-preview-head">
+            <div>
+                <p class="market-intel-muted momo-mono mb-1">MCP / WRITER CLI REVIEW</p>
+                <h2 class="market-intel-preview-title">MCP Candidate Queue Writer CLI Review</h2>
+            </div>
+            <button class="market-intel-icon-button" type="button" title="重新整理 MCP Writer CLI Review" data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-refresh>
+                <i class="fas fa-rotate-right" aria-hidden="true"></i>
+            </button>
+        </div>
+        <div class="market-intel-preview-meta" data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-meta>
+            <span class="market-intel-pill">loading</span>
+        </div>
+        <div data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-body>
+            <div class="market-intel-empty">讀取 MCP Writer CLI Review 中...</div>
+        </div>
+        <div class="market-intel-control-row mt-3">
+            <textarea class="market-intel-json-input" rows="9" spellcheck="false" data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-input placeholder="writer preflight and CLI review JSON"></textarea>
+            <div class="market-intel-control-actions">
+                <button class="market-intel-icon-button" type="button" title="審核 MCP Writer CLI Review JSON" data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-review>
+                    <i class="fas fa-check" aria-hidden="true"></i>
+                </button>
+            </div>
+        </div>
+    </div>
+
     <div class="market-intel-panel" data-market-intel-manual-sample>
         <div class="market-intel-preview-head">
             <div>
@@ -1380,6 +1406,7 @@
         const mcpFetchCandidateHandoffReviewRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-handoff-review]');
         const mcpFetchCandidateQueueReviewRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-review]');
         const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-preflight]');
+        const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review]');
         const manualSampleRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-manual-sample]');
         const sampleAcceptanceRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-acceptance]');
         const sampleReviewRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-review]');
@@ -1396,7 +1423,7 @@
         const liveInventoryRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-live-inventory]');
         const approvalRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-approval]');
         const deployRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-deploy]');
-        if (!root && !writerRoot && !cliRoot && !dbProbeRoot && !seedDiffRoot && !legacyBridgeRoot && !mcpReadinessRoot && !mcpPreflightRoot && !mcpActivationRoot && !mcpFetchGateRoot && !mcpCompletionRoot && !mcpActivationEvidenceRoot && !mcpRuntimeSmokeRoot && !mcpRuntimePromotionRoot && !mcpManualFetchHandoffRoot && !mcpFetchTargetReviewRoot && !mcpFetchRunPackageRoot && !mcpFetchRunReadinessRoot && !mcpFetchRunReceiptRoot && !mcpFetchResultParserReviewRoot && !mcpFetchCandidateHandoffReviewRoot && !mcpFetchCandidateQueueReviewRoot && !mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRoot && !manualSampleRoot && !sampleAcceptanceRoot && !sampleReviewRoot && !schedulerRoot && !matchReviewRoot && !opportunityRoot && !opportunityScoringRoot && !opportunityEvidenceRoot && !opportunityAlertRoot && !migrationRoot && !migrationDrillRoot && !catalogReviewRoot && !liveSmokeRoot && !liveInventoryRoot && !approvalRoot && !deployRoot) return;
+        if (!root && !writerRoot && !cliRoot && !dbProbeRoot && !seedDiffRoot && !legacyBridgeRoot && !mcpReadinessRoot && !mcpPreflightRoot && !mcpActivationRoot && !mcpFetchGateRoot && !mcpCompletionRoot && !mcpActivationEvidenceRoot && !mcpRuntimeSmokeRoot && !mcpRuntimePromotionRoot && !mcpManualFetchHandoffRoot && !mcpFetchTargetReviewRoot && !mcpFetchRunPackageRoot && !mcpFetchRunReadinessRoot && !mcpFetchRunReceiptRoot && !mcpFetchResultParserReviewRoot && !mcpFetchCandidateHandoffReviewRoot && !mcpFetchCandidateQueueReviewRoot && !mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRoot && !mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot && !manualSampleRoot && !sampleAcceptanceRoot && !sampleReviewRoot && !schedulerRoot && !matchReviewRoot && !opportunityRoot && !opportunityScoringRoot && !opportunityEvidenceRoot && !opportunityAlertRoot && !migrationRoot && !migrationDrillRoot && !catalogReviewRoot && !liveSmokeRoot && !liveInventoryRoot && !approvalRoot && !deployRoot) return;
 
         const meta = root ? root.querySelector('[data-market-intel-preview-meta]') : null;
         const body = root ? root.querySelector('[data-market-intel-preview-body]') : null;
@@ -1515,6 +1542,12 @@
         const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightReview = mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRoot ? mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-preflight-review]') : null;
         const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRefresh = mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRoot ? mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-preflight-refresh]') : null;
         const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel.market_intel_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_preflight') }}";
+        const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta = mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot ? mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-meta]') : null;
+        const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody = mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot ? mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-body]') : null;
+        const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewInput = mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot ? mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-input]') : null;
+        const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewReview = mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot ? mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-review]') : null;
+        const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRefresh = mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot ? mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-refresh]') : null;
+        const mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel.market_intel_mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review') }}";
         const manualSampleMeta = manualSampleRoot ? manualSampleRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-manual-sample-meta]') : null;
         const manualSampleBody = manualSampleRoot ? manualSampleRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-manual-sample-body]') : null;
         const manualSampleRefresh = manualSampleRoot ? manualSampleRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-manual-sample-refresh]') : null;
@@ -3981,6 +4014,134 @@
             }
         };
 
+        const renderMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta = data => {
+            mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta.innerHTML = [
+                `mode=${data.mode || 'unknown'}`,
+                `accepted=${data.mcp_fetch_candidate_queue_writer_cli_review_accepted ? 'yes' : 'no'}`,
+                `gates=${data.passed_gate_count || 0}/${data.gate_count || 0}`,
+                `rows=${data.payload_row_count || 0}`,
+                `cli=${data.api_executes_cli ? 'exec' : 'blocked'}`,
+                `db=${data.api_writes_database ? 'write' : 'blocked'}`
+            ].map(item => `<span class="market-intel-pill">${escapeHtml(item)}</span>`).join('');
+        };
+
+        const renderMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody = data => {
+            const blockers = (data.blocked_reasons || []).join(' / ');
+            const gates = data.gates || [];
+            const preflight = data.writer_preflight_summary || {};
+            const review = data.writer_cli_review_summary || {};
+            const argv = review.command_argv_preview || [];
+            const steps = data.next_operator_steps || [];
+            const renderCheck = (key, label, status) => `
+                <div class="market-intel-check">
+                    <div>
+                        <strong>${escapeHtml(key)}</strong>
+                        <small>${escapeHtml(label || '')}</small>
+                    </div>
+                    <span>${escapeHtml(status)}</span>
+                </div>
+            `;
+            mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody.innerHTML = `
+                <div class="market-intel-empty mb-3">此 CLI review 只審核人工 shell writer 草案；API 不執行 CLI、不讀 approval token、不寫檔、不開 DB、不寫 queue、不掛 scheduler。${blockers ? `阻擋：${escapeHtml(blockers)}` : ''}</div>
+                <div class="market-intel-deploy-grid">
+                    <div data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-gates>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">CLI REVIEW GATES</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            gates.length
+                                ? gates.map(item => renderCheck(item.key, item.label, item.passed ? 'PASS' : 'BLOCK')).join('')
+                                : '<div class="market-intel-empty">尚未提供 CLI review gates。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-preflight>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">PREFLIGHT LINK</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">
+                            ${renderCheck('writer_preflight', `${preflight.accepted ? 'accepted' : 'pending'} / rows=${preflight.payload_row_count || 0}`, preflight.accepted ? 'ACCEPTED' : 'PENDING')}
+                            ${renderCheck('preflight_id', preflight.preflight_id || 'missing', preflight.preflight_id ? 'LINKED' : 'BLOCK')}
+                            ${renderCheck('preflight_boundary', 'no CLI / no DB / no scheduler', preflight.side_effects_clear ? 'CLOSED' : 'BLOCK')}
+                        </div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-command>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">COMMAND REVIEW</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">
+                            ${renderCheck('script_path', review.script_path || 'missing', review.script_path === 'scripts/market_intel_candidate_queue_writer.py' ? 'READY' : 'BLOCK')}
+                            ${renderCheck('command_mode', review.command_mode || 'missing', review.command_mode === 'manual_shell_review_only' ? 'MANUAL' : 'BLOCK')}
+                            ${renderCheck('safe_flags', argv.join(' '), review.required_safe_flags_present ? 'READY' : 'BLOCK')}
+                            ${renderCheck('forbidden_flags', '--execute / --apply-real-write / --approval-token', review.forbidden_command_flags_absent ? 'ABSENT' : 'BLOCK')}
+                        </div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-payload>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">PAYLOAD CONTRACT</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">
+                            ${renderCheck('target_table', review.target_table || 'missing', review.target_table === 'market_alert_review_queue' ? 'TARGET' : 'BLOCK')}
+                            ${renderCheck('row_count', `${review.expected_payload_row_count || 0}`, review.expected_payload_row_count === preflight.payload_row_count ? 'MATCH' : 'BLOCK')}
+                            ${renderCheck('candidate_keys', `${(review.expected_candidate_keys || []).length}`, review.candidate_keys_unique ? 'UNIQUE' : 'BLOCK')}
+                            ${renderCheck('dedupe_keys', `${(review.expected_dedupe_keys || []).length}`, review.dedupe_keys_unique ? 'UNIQUE' : 'BLOCK')}
+                        </div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-candidate-queue-writer-cli-review-next>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">BOUNDARY / NEXT</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">
+                            ${renderCheck(
+                                'api_boundary',
+                                'no CLI / no token / no DB / no queue write / no scheduler',
+                                data.api_executes_cli || data.api_reads_approval_token || data.api_writes_database ? 'BLOCK' : 'CLOSED'
+                            )}
+                            ${steps.map((item, index) => renderCheck(`step_${index + 1}`, item, 'NEXT')).join('')}
+                        </div>
+                    </div>
+                </div>
+            `;
+            if (mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewInput && !mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewInput.value.trim() && data.sample_writer_cli_review_package) {
+                mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewInput.value = JSON.stringify(data.sample_writer_cli_review_package, null, 2);
+            }
+        };
+
+        const loadMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReview = async () => {
+            if (!mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta || !mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody) return;
+            mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody.innerHTML = '<div class="market-intel-empty">讀取 MCP Writer CLI Review 中...</div>';
+            try {
+                const response = await fetch(mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewEndpoint, { credentials: 'same-origin' });
+                if (!response.ok) throw new Error(`HTTP ${response.status}`);
+                const data = await response.json();
+                renderMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta(data);
+                renderMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody(data);
+            } catch (error) {
+                mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta.innerHTML = '<span class="market-intel-pill">error</span>';
+                mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody.innerHTML = `<div class="market-intel-empty">MCP Writer CLI Review 讀取失敗：${escapeHtml(error.message)}</div>`;
+            }
+        };
+
+        const reviewMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReview = async () => {
+            if (!mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta || !mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody || !mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewInput) return;
+            let parsed;
+            try {
+                parsed = JSON.parse(mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewInput.value || '{}');
+            } catch (error) {
+                mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta.innerHTML = '<span class="market-intel-pill">json_error</span>';
+                mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody.innerHTML = `<div class="market-intel-empty">JSON 格式錯誤：${escapeHtml(error.message)}</div>`;
+                return;
+            }
+            mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody.innerHTML = '<div class="market-intel-empty">審核 MCP Writer CLI Review 中...</div>';
+            try {
+                const response = await fetch(mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewEndpoint, {
+                    method: 'POST',
+                    credentials: 'same-origin',
+                    headers: {
+                        'Content-Type': 'application/json',
+                        'X-CSRFToken': csrfToken
+                    },
+                    body: JSON.stringify({ writer_cli_review_package: parsed })
+                });
+                const data = await response.json();
+                if (!response.ok && !data.mode) throw new Error(`HTTP ${response.status}`);
+                renderMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta(data);
+                renderMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody(data);
+            } catch (error) {
+                mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewMeta.innerHTML = '<span class="market-intel-pill">error</span>';
+                mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewBody.innerHTML = `<div class="market-intel-empty">MCP Writer CLI Review 審核失敗：${escapeHtml(error.message)}</div>`;
+            }
+        };
+
         const renderManualSampleMeta = data => {
             manualSampleMeta.innerHTML = [
                 `mode=${data.mode || 'unknown'}`,
@@ -13456,6 +13617,12 @@
         if (mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightReview) {
             mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflightReview.addEventListener('click', reviewMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflight);
         }
+        if (mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRefresh) {
+            mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewRefresh.addEventListener('click', loadMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReview);
+        }
+        if (mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewReview) {
+            mcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReviewReview.addEventListener('click', reviewMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReview);
+        }
         if (manualSampleRefresh) {
             manualSampleRefresh.addEventListener('click', loadManualSample);
         }
@@ -13722,6 +13889,7 @@
         loadMcpFetchCandidateHandoffReview();
         loadMcpFetchCandidateQueueReview();
         loadMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterPreflight();
+        loadMcpFetchCandidateQueueWriterCliReview();
         loadManualSample();
         loadSampleAcceptance();
         loadSampleReview();