新增市場情報 review decision writer operator drill

TODO_NEXT_STEPS.txt

@@ -144,6 +144,7 @@
    - Phase 70 candidate queue review decision writer preflight：新增 `services/market_intel/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight.py`、POST `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight` 與 UI preflight 按鈕，檢查 writer status、review_state update payload、狀態轉換與禁止 token 進 API；API/UI 即使收到 execute/apply_real_write 也不連 DB、不執行 CLI、不更新 review_state、不 commit、不讀 token、不掛 scheduler；版本同步至 V10.258。
    - V10.259 補 Phase 70 preflight 合約與 OCLearn queue 時區：preflight 補 planned/read-only catalog probe 欄位、dedupe unique index 檢查與 route 重複註冊清理；OCLearn embedding queue 的 created_at/updated_at/stale cutoff 改為台北 naive，避免 UTC/台北時間差讓 processing 任務卡住。
    - Phase 71 candidate queue review decision writer post-write smoke：新增 `services/market_intel/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke.py`、POST `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke` 與 UI smoke 按鈕，人工 CLI 更新 review_state 後可用 dedupe key 只讀驗證 row 是否存在且 state 符合預期；API/UI 預設不連 DB，execute=true 也只讀查詢，不更新 review_state、不 commit、不讀 token、不掛 scheduler；版本同步至 V10.260。
+   - Phase 72 candidate queue review decision writer operator drill：新增 `services/market_intel/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill.py`、POST `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill` 與 UI drill 按鈕，將 review_state CLI 更新前後的 transaction JSON、備份、preflight、CLI writer、post-write smoke 與 rollback plan 組成可稽核操作順序；API/UI 不讀 token、不執行 CLI、不連 DB、不更新 review_state、不 commit、不掛 scheduler；版本同步至 V10.261。
    - V10.248 補市場情報 390px preview panel QA：sample review 工具列改為 textarea + 可換行 action rail，移除舊的硬編 8 欄 grid；`check_responsive_overflow` 新增 `--screenshot-all`，本機 390x844 `/market_intel` 真頁面 QA 通過且 overflow=0。
    - V10.250 補 Code Review Gemini 備援遙測護欄：Ollama 主路徑失敗時 `fallback_to` 明確指向 `code_review_openclaw_gemini`，測試鎖住「Gemini 不得記成 `code_review_openclaw` 主 caller」；AI Calls 觀測台會把 legacy `code_review_openclaw + gemini` 顯示成 Gemini 備援，避免誤判 Gemini-first。
    - Schema smoke：`tests/test_market_intel_skeleton.py` 檢查 `Base.metadata` 內含 ADR-035 八張 `market_*` tables。

config.py

@@ -320,7 +320,7 @@ YOUTUBE_API_KEY = os.getenv('YOUTUBE_API_KEY', '')
 # ==========================================
 # 系統版本與路徑
 # ==========================================
-SYSTEM_VERSION = "V10.260"
+SYSTEM_VERSION = "V10.261"
 LOG_FILE_PATH = os.path.join(BASE_DIR, 'logs/system.log')
 public_url = PUBLIC_URL  # 用於模板顯示
 

docs/adr/ADR-035-cross-platform-market-campaign-intelligence.md

@@ -197,6 +197,7 @@ EwoooC 目前已有 MOMO EDM / 節慶活動資料、`promo_products`、PChome
 - 2026-05-19 追加 candidate queue review decision writer CLI gate：`services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli`、`scripts/market_intel_review_decision_writer.py` 與 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status` 先建立 review_state writer 的 shell-only gate、一次性 token env var、command bundle 與 rollback plan。此階段 writer implementation 保持 disabled；API/UI 不讀 approval token、不執行 CLI、不連 DB、不開 transaction、不 commit、不更新 `review_state`、不掛 scheduler。
 - 2026-05-19 追加 candidate queue review decision writer preflight：`services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight` 與 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight` 檢查 writer status、review_state update payload、狀態轉換與 token 外洩風險。API/UI 即使收到 `execute=true` 或 `apply_real_write=true` 也只回 blocked preview，不連 DB、不執行 CLI、不更新 `review_state`、不 commit、不讀 approval token、不掛 scheduler。
 - 2026-05-19 追加 candidate queue review decision writer post-write smoke：`services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke` 與 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke` 依 review_state transaction preview 的 dedupe key 只讀查詢 `market_alert_review_queue`，確認人工 CLI 更新後的 `review_state` 是否符合預期。UI 預設 `execute=false` 不連 DB；人工 smoke 即使 `execute=true` 也只讀查詢，不更新 `review_state`、不 commit、不讀 approval token、不掛 scheduler。
+- 2026-05-19 追加 candidate queue review decision writer operator drill：`services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill` 與 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill` 整理 review_state CLI 更新前後的操作員順序、preflight、post-write smoke、gate 與 rollback plan。此 drill 只輸出可稽核操作計畫；API/UI 不讀 approval token、不執行 CLI、不連 DB、不更新 `review_state`、不 commit、不掛 scheduler。
 
 ### Phase 4：Coupang / Shopee Adapter
 

routes/README.md

@@ -19,8 +19,8 @@
 | `edm_routes.py` | EDM 與節慶儀表板 | `/edm`, `/festival` |
 | `monthly_routes.py` | 月結分析 | `/monthly_summary_analysis`, `/api/monthly_summary_data` |
 | `daily_sales_routes.py` | 當日業績 | `/daily_sales`, `/daily_sales/export*` |
-| `market_intel_routes.py` | 市場情報 Phase 71 candidate queue review decision writer post-write smoke 主路由 | `/market_intel`, `/market_intel/*`, `/api/market_intel/status`, `/api/market_intel/schema`, `/api/market_intel/schema_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/schema_db_probe`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_db_diff`, `/api/market_intel/legacy_source_bridge`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_readiness`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_tool_contract`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_deploy_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_activation_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_gate`, `/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/evaluate`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_handoff`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_draft`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_approval`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_transaction`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_status`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_operator_drill`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_package`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_readiness`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_closeout`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_handoff`, `/api/market_intel/match_review_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_evidence_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_alert_plan`, `/api/market_intel/adapters`, `/api/market_intel/dry_run_plan`, `/api/market_intel/discovery_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_discovery`, `/api/market_intel/candidate_preview`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_plan`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_write_guard`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_writer_plan`, `/api/market_intel/migration_blueprint`, `/api/market_intel/migration_apply_drill`, `/api/market_intel/migration_catalog_review`, `/api/market_intel/migration_live_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory`, `/api/market_intel/seed_writer_cli_status`, `/api/market_intel/write_approval_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/deployment_readiness` |
-| `market_intel_review_routes.py` | 市場情報人工 queue review 只讀延伸 API | `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_inventory`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_approval`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke` |
+| `market_intel_routes.py` | 市場情報 Phase 72 candidate queue review decision writer operator drill 主路由 | `/market_intel`, `/market_intel/*`, `/api/market_intel/status`, `/api/market_intel/schema`, `/api/market_intel/schema_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/schema_db_probe`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_db_diff`, `/api/market_intel/legacy_source_bridge`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_readiness`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_tool_contract`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_deploy_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_activation_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_gate`, `/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/evaluate`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_handoff`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_draft`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_approval`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_transaction`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_status`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_operator_drill`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_package`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_readiness`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_closeout`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_handoff`, `/api/market_intel/match_review_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_evidence_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_alert_plan`, `/api/market_intel/adapters`, `/api/market_intel/dry_run_plan`, `/api/market_intel/discovery_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_discovery`, `/api/market_intel/candidate_preview`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_plan`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_write_guard`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_writer_plan`, `/api/market_intel/migration_blueprint`, `/api/market_intel/migration_apply_drill`, `/api/market_intel/migration_catalog_review`, `/api/market_intel/migration_live_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory`, `/api/market_intel/seed_writer_cli_status`, `/api/market_intel/write_approval_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/deployment_readiness` |
+| `market_intel_review_routes.py` | 市場情報人工 queue review 只讀延伸 API | `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_inventory`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_approval`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill` |
 | `api_routes.py` | 通用任務與查詢 API | `/api/run_task`, `/api/history/*` |
 | `export_routes.py` | 匯出功能 | `/api/export/*` |
 | `import_routes.py` | 匯入功能 | `/api/import_excel`, `/api/import/monthly_summary` |

routes/market_intel_review_routes.py

@@ -30,6 +30,9 @@ from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight impo
 from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke import (
     build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke,
 )
+from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill import (
+    build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill,
+)
 from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_writer_cli import (
     build_candidate_queue_writer_cli_plan,
 )
@@ -238,6 +241,80 @@ def _build_review_decision_transaction_stack(
     )
 
 
+def _live_inventory_from_postwrite_smoke(postwrite_smoke_result):
+    postwrite_smoke_result = (
+        postwrite_smoke_result if isinstance(postwrite_smoke_result, dict) else {}
+    )
+    row_summaries = postwrite_smoke_result.get("row_summaries") or []
+    return {
+        "mode": "live_db_inventory_from_postwrite_smoke_preview",
+        "summary_ready": bool(postwrite_smoke_result.get("postwrite_smoke_passed")),
+        "read_only_query_executed": bool(
+            postwrite_smoke_result.get("read_only_query_executed")
+        ),
+        "database_connection_opened": False,
+        "database_session_created": False,
+        "database_write_executed": False,
+        "database_commit_executed": False,
+        "external_network_executed": False,
+        "scheduler_attached": False,
+        "writes_executed": False,
+        "would_write_database": False,
+        "total_rows": postwrite_smoke_result.get("found_count"),
+        "alert_review_state_breakdown": [],
+        "table_statuses": [
+            {
+                "table": "market_alert_review_queue",
+                "exists": bool(row_summaries),
+                "row_count": len(row_summaries),
+                "status": "from_postwrite_smoke_result",
+            }
+        ],
+    }
+
+
+def _build_review_decision_transaction_stack_from_postwrite_evidence(
+    *,
+    service,
+    sample_result,
+    payload_error,
+    operator_evidence,
+    writer_output,
+    postwrite_smoke_result,
+    limit,
+):
+    transaction_preview, handoff = _build_closeout_stack(
+        service=service,
+        sample_result=sample_result,
+        payload_error=payload_error,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+        writer_output=writer_output,
+        postwrite_smoke_result=postwrite_smoke_result,
+        limit=limit,
+    )
+    inventory = build_candidate_queue_review_inventory(
+        review_handoff=handoff,
+        postwrite_smoke=postwrite_smoke_result,
+        live_db_inventory=_live_inventory_from_postwrite_smoke(
+            postwrite_smoke_result
+        ),
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+        execute_requested=False,
+    )
+    decision = build_candidate_queue_review_decision(
+        review_inventory=inventory,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+    )
+    approval = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_approval(
+        review_decision=decision,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+    )
+    return build_candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction(
+        decision_approval=approval,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+    )
+
+
 @market_intel_review_bp.route(
     "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_inventory",
     methods=["POST"],
@@ -448,7 +525,7 @@ def market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_
     sample_result, operator_evidence, writer_output, smoke_result, payload_error, limit = (
         _extract_run_payload()
     )
-    transaction = _build_review_decision_transaction_stack(
+    transaction = _build_review_decision_transaction_stack_from_postwrite_evidence(
         service=service,
         sample_result=sample_result,
         payload_error=payload_error,
@@ -456,7 +533,6 @@ def market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_
         writer_output=writer_output,
         postwrite_smoke_result=smoke_result,
         limit=limit,
-        execute_requested=False,
     )
     data = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke(
         transaction_preview=transaction,
@@ -464,3 +540,55 @@ def market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_
     )
     data["phase"] = service.phase
     return jsonify(data), 400 if payload_error else 200
+
+
+@market_intel_review_bp.route(
+    "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/"
+    "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill",
+    methods=["POST"],
+)
+@login_required
+def market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill():
+    service = MarketIntelService()
+    sample_result, operator_evidence, writer_output, smoke_result, payload_error, limit = (
+        _extract_run_payload()
+    )
+    transaction = _build_review_decision_transaction_stack_from_postwrite_evidence(
+        service=service,
+        sample_result=sample_result,
+        payload_error=payload_error,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+        writer_output=writer_output,
+        postwrite_smoke_result=smoke_result,
+        limit=limit,
+    )
+    writer_status = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_plan(
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+        execute_requested=False,
+        apply_real_write=False,
+        approval_token=None,
+        approval_token_secret=None,
+        backup_verified=False,
+        review_inventory_smoke_passed=False,
+    )
+    writer_preflight = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight(
+        writer_status=writer_status,
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+        execute_requested=False,
+        apply_real_write=False,
+    )
+    postwrite_smoke = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke(
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        execute_requested=False,
+    )
+    data = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill(
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        writer_preflight=writer_preflight,
+        writer_status=writer_status,
+        postwrite_smoke=postwrite_smoke,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+    )
+    data["phase"] = service.phase
+    return jsonify(data), 400 if payload_error else 200

services/market_intel/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill.py

@@ -0,0 +1,360 @@
+"""候選審核 queue review_state writer operator drill preview。
+
+本模組只組裝人工 CLI 更新 review_state 的操作順序與 gate；
+不讀 approval token、不開 DB connection、不更新 review_state、不 commit、不掛 scheduler。
+"""
+
+from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction import (
+    ALLOWED_DECISIONS,
+    TARGET_TABLE,
+)
+
+
+FORBIDDEN_TOKEN_KEYWORDS = (
+    "approval_token",
+    "approval-token",
+    "market_intel_queue_write_approval",
+)
+SAFE_TOKEN_METADATA_KEYS = {
+    "approval_token_present",
+    "approval_token_valid",
+    "approval_token_secret_configured",
+}
+SAFE_APPROVAL_ENV_VAR = "MARKET_INTEL_QUEUE_WRITE_APPROVAL"
+
+
+def _as_dict(value):
+    return value if isinstance(value, dict) else {}
+
+
+def _as_list(value):
+    if value is None:
+        return []
+    if isinstance(value, (list, tuple, set)):
+        return list(value)
+    return [value]
+
+
+def _contains_forbidden_token_key(value):
+    if isinstance(value, dict):
+        for key, nested in value.items():
+            normalized_key = str(key).lower()
+            if normalized_key in SAFE_TOKEN_METADATA_KEYS and isinstance(nested, bool):
+                continue
+            if normalized_key == "approval_env_var" and nested == SAFE_APPROVAL_ENV_VAR:
+                continue
+            if any(token_key in normalized_key for token_key in FORBIDDEN_TOKEN_KEYWORDS):
+                return True
+            if _contains_forbidden_token_key(nested):
+                return True
+    elif isinstance(value, list):
+        return any(_contains_forbidden_token_key(item) for item in value)
+    return False
+
+
+def _statement_summary(transaction_preview):
+    transaction_preview = _as_dict(transaction_preview)
+    statements = [_as_dict(item) for item in _as_list(transaction_preview.get("statements"))]
+    invalid = []
+    updates = []
+    for statement in statements:
+        parameter_preview = _as_dict(statement.get("parameter_preview"))
+        dedupe_key = parameter_preview.get("dedupe_key") or _as_dict(
+            statement.get("lookup")
+        ).get("dedupe_key")
+        current_state = (
+            parameter_preview.get("expected_current_review_state")
+            or statement.get("expected_current_review_state")
+        )
+        next_state = parameter_preview.get("next_review_state") or statement.get(
+            "next_review_state"
+        )
+        updates.append(
+            {
+                "idempotency_key": statement.get("idempotency_key"),
+                "dedupe_key": dedupe_key,
+                "expected_current_review_state": current_state,
+                "next_review_state": next_state,
+                "operation": statement.get("operation"),
+                "statement_type": statement.get("statement_type"),
+                "parameter_payload_hash": statement.get("parameter_payload_hash"),
+            }
+        )
+        if (
+            not dedupe_key
+            or current_state != "needs_review"
+            or next_state not in ALLOWED_DECISIONS
+            or statement.get("operation") != "update"
+            or statement.get("statement_type") != "update_review_state"
+        ):
+            invalid.append(statement.get("idempotency_key") or dedupe_key or "unknown")
+    summary = _as_dict(transaction_preview.get("transaction_preview_summary"))
+    return {
+        "transaction_preview_created": bool(
+            transaction_preview.get("transaction_preview_created")
+        ),
+        "transaction_ready": bool(transaction_preview.get("transaction_ready")),
+        "statement_count": int(summary.get("statement_count") or len(statements)),
+        "invalid_statement_count": len(invalid),
+        "invalid_statement_keys": invalid,
+        "allowed_next_states": list(ALLOWED_DECISIONS),
+        "review_state_updates": updates,
+        "target_table": transaction_preview.get("target_table") or TARGET_TABLE,
+    }
+
+
+def _operator_summary(operator_evidence):
+    operator_evidence = _as_dict(operator_evidence)
+    return {
+        "provided_keys": sorted(operator_evidence.keys()),
+        "operator_confirmed_manual_shell_window": bool(
+            operator_evidence.get("operator_confirmed_manual_shell_window")
+        ),
+        "operator_confirmed_transaction_payload_reviewed": bool(
+            operator_evidence.get("operator_confirmed_transaction_payload_reviewed")
+        ),
+        "operator_confirmed_review_state_update_is_not_api": bool(
+            operator_evidence.get("operator_confirmed_review_state_update_is_not_api")
+        ),
+        "operator_confirmed_post_update_inventory_planned": bool(
+            operator_evidence.get("operator_confirmed_post_update_inventory_planned")
+        ),
+        "operator_confirmed_no_api_db_write": bool(
+            operator_evidence.get("operator_confirmed_no_api_db_write")
+        ),
+        "operator_confirmed_no_scheduler_attach": bool(
+            operator_evidence.get("operator_confirmed_no_scheduler_attach")
+        ),
+        "operator_drill_notes_present": bool(
+            str(operator_evidence.get("operator_drill_notes") or "").strip()
+        ),
+        "approval_token_submitted_to_api": _contains_forbidden_token_key(
+            operator_evidence
+        ),
+    }
+
+
+def _gates(statement_summary, operator_summary, writer_preflight, writer_status, postwrite_smoke):
+    return [
+        {
+            "key": "transaction_preview_created",
+            "label": "已產生 review_state transaction preview",
+            "passed": statement_summary["transaction_preview_created"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "transaction_ready_for_manual_shell_update",
+            "label": "transaction preview 已通過人工 shell 更新前置 gate",
+            "passed": statement_summary["transaction_ready"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "transaction_has_update_statements",
+            "label": "transaction preview 至少有一筆 update_review_state statement",
+            "passed": statement_summary["statement_count"] > 0,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "transaction_statements_valid",
+            "label": "statement 只能把 needs_review 更新為 confirmed / rejected / deferred",
+            "passed": bool(
+                statement_summary["statement_count"]
+                and statement_summary["invalid_statement_count"] == 0
+            ),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_preflight_available",
+            "label": "writer preflight 已可用，正式操作前需人工跑只讀檢查",
+            "passed": bool(writer_preflight),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "writer_cli_gate_available",
+            "label": "review_state writer CLI gate 已可用，真更新只允許 CLI 執行",
+            "passed": bool(writer_status),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "postwrite_smoke_available",
+            "label": "post-write smoke 已可用，更新後可只讀驗證 review_state",
+            "passed": bool(postwrite_smoke),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "operator_reviewed_transaction_payload",
+            "label": "操作員已人工確認 transaction payload",
+            "passed": operator_summary["operator_confirmed_transaction_payload_reviewed"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "manual_shell_window_acknowledged",
+            "label": "操作員確認只能在人工 shell 寫入窗口執行",
+            "passed": operator_summary["operator_confirmed_manual_shell_window"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "post_update_inventory_planned",
+            "label": "操作員確認正式更新後會執行只讀 inventory / smoke",
+            "passed": operator_summary["operator_confirmed_post_update_inventory_planned"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "operator_confirmed_no_api_db_write_or_scheduler",
+            "label": "操作員確認 API/UI 不寫 DB、不掛 scheduler",
+            "passed": bool(
+                operator_summary["operator_confirmed_no_api_db_write"]
+                and operator_summary["operator_confirmed_no_scheduler_attach"]
+                and operator_summary["operator_confirmed_review_state_update_is_not_api"]
+            ),
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "operator_drill_notes_present",
+            "label": "operator drill 需留下 notes，方便人工稽核",
+            "passed": operator_summary["operator_drill_notes_present"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "operator_drill_no_token_submitted_to_api",
+            "label": "operator_evidence 不得包含一次性 approval token key",
+            "passed": not operator_summary["approval_token_submitted_to_api"],
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "api_does_not_execute_write",
+            "label": "API/UI 不讀 token、不替操作員執行 DB 更新",
+            "passed": True,
+        },
+        {
+            "key": "backup_verified_by_operator",
+            "label": "正式更新前操作員必須完成備份並保留備份檔路徑",
+            "passed": False,
+        },
+    ]
+
+
+def build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill(
+    *,
+    transaction_preview,
+    writer_preflight,
+    writer_status,
+    postwrite_smoke,
+    operator_evidence=None,
+):
+    """建立 review_state writer operator drill preview；不執行 DB 或 CLI。"""
+    statement_summary = _statement_summary(transaction_preview)
+    operator_summary = _operator_summary(operator_evidence)
+    gates = _gates(
+        statement_summary,
+        operator_summary,
+        _as_dict(writer_preflight),
+        _as_dict(writer_status),
+        _as_dict(postwrite_smoke),
+    )
+    blocked_reasons = [gate["key"] for gate in gates if not gate["passed"]]
+    command_sequence = [
+        {
+            "step": 1,
+            "key": "render_review_state_transaction_json",
+            "label": "將已批准的 review_state transaction preview 存成本機 JSON",
+            "command_shape": "write local review-state-transaction.json outside API",
+            "executes_database": False,
+        },
+        {
+            "step": 2,
+            "key": "run_backup",
+            "label": "正式更新前先執行專案備份",
+            "command_shape": "python3 scripts/tools/backup_system.py",
+            "executes_database": False,
+        },
+        {
+            "step": 3,
+            "key": "run_read_only_preflight",
+            "label": "只讀確認 review queue 欄位、dedupe lookup 與 update contract",
+            "command_shape": (
+                "python3 scripts/market_intel_review_decision_writer.py "
+                "--transaction-json review-state-transaction.json --read-only-preflight"
+            ),
+            "executes_database": False,
+        },
+        {
+            "step": 4,
+            "key": "run_cli_review_state_writer",
+            "label": "只在 CLI shell 以一次性 token 執行受控 review_state update",
+            "command_shape": (
+                "MARKET_INTEL_QUEUE_WRITE_APPROVAL=... "
+                "python3 scripts/market_intel_review_decision_writer.py --execute "
+                "--apply-real-write --transaction-json review-state-transaction.json"
+            ),
+            "executes_database": True,
+        },
+        {
+            "step": 5,
+            "key": "run_postwrite_smoke",
+            "label": "更新後用 dedupe key 只讀確認 review_state 是否符合預期",
+            "command_shape": (
+                "POST /api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/"
+                "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke?execute=true"
+            ),
+            "executes_database": False,
+        },
+    ]
+    return {
+        "mode": "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview",
+        "target_table": TARGET_TABLE,
+        "target_operation": "update_review_state",
+        "operator_drill_ready": bool(
+            statement_summary["transaction_preview_created"]
+            and statement_summary["statement_count"] > 0
+            and statement_summary["invalid_statement_count"] == 0
+            and not operator_summary["approval_token_submitted_to_api"]
+        ),
+        "ready_for_api_review_state_update": False,
+        "ready_for_api_database_write": False,
+        "ready_for_scheduler_attach": False,
+        "api_executes_cli": False,
+        "api_reads_approval_token": False,
+        "api_writes_file": False,
+        "api_writes_database": False,
+        "api_updates_review_state": False,
+        "approval_record_written": False,
+        "decision_record_written": False,
+        "review_state_update_executed": False,
+        "database_connection_opened": False,
+        "database_session_created": False,
+        "explicit_transaction_opened": False,
+        "transaction_opened": False,
+        "transaction_committed": False,
+        "database_write_executed": False,
+        "database_commit_executed": False,
+        "database_rollback_executed": False,
+        "external_network_executed": False,
+        "scheduler_attached": False,
+        "writes_executed": False,
+        "would_write_database": False,
+        "blocked_reasons": blocked_reasons,
+        "statement_summary": statement_summary,
+        "operator_drill_summary": operator_summary,
+        "gates": gates,
+        "command_sequence": command_sequence,
+        "input_summaries": {
+            "writer_preflight_mode": _as_dict(writer_preflight).get("mode"),
+            "writer_status_mode": _as_dict(writer_status).get("mode"),
+            "postwrite_smoke_mode": _as_dict(postwrite_smoke).get("mode"),
+            "postwrite_smoke_execute_requested": bool(
+                _as_dict(postwrite_smoke).get("execute_requested")
+            ),
+        },
+        "rollback_plan": [
+            {
+                "key": "no_write_no_db_rollback_required",
+                "label": "若 drill preview 或任一 gate 阻擋，沒有 DB rollback 需求",
+            },
+            {
+                "key": "review_state_reversal_requires_manual_audit",
+                "label": "若 CLI 真更新後需回退，必須依 dedupe_key 與審核證據人工稽核",
+            },
+            {
+                "key": "disable_market_intel_flags",
+                "label": "異常時維持 MARKET_INTEL_* flags 關閉並回退 momo-app 程式碼",
+            },
+        ],
+        "safe_boundaries": [
+            "do_not_execute_review_state_writer_from_operator_drill_api",
+            "do_not_read_approval_token_from_operator_drill_api",
+            "do_not_open_database_connection_from_review_state_operator_drill",
+            "do_not_update_review_state_from_review_state_operator_drill",
+            "do_not_commit_review_state_operator_drill",
+            "do_not_attach_scheduler_from_review_state_operator_drill",
+            "no_remove_orphans",
+            "no_momo_db_lifecycle_change",
+        ],
+    }

services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py

@@ -19,10 +19,11 @@ from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction import bu
 from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli import build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_plan
 from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight import build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight
 from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke import build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke
+from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill import build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill
 
 
 BLOCKED_RUN_REVIEW_KEYS = ("ready_for_api_database_write", "ready_for_scheduler_attach", "api_executes_cli", "api_reads_approval_token", "api_writes_file", "api_writes_database", "api_updates_review_state", "approval_record_written", "decision_record_written", "review_state_update_executed", "database_connection_opened", "database_session_created", "explicit_transaction_opened", "transaction_opened", "transaction_committed", "database_write_executed", "database_commit_executed", "database_rollback_executed", "scheduler_attached", "writes_executed", "would_write_database")
-PRODUCTION_SMOKE_TARGETS = ("/health", "/market_intel", "/api/market_intel/status", "/api/market_intel/deployment_readiness", "/api/market_intel/schema_smoke", "/api/market_intel/schema_db_probe", "/api/market_intel/platform_seed_db_diff", "/api/market_intel/legacy_source_bridge", "/api/market_intel/mcp_readiness", "/api/market_intel/mcp_tool_contract", "/api/market_intel/mcp_deploy_preflight", "/api/market_intel/mcp_activation_runbook", "/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_gate", "/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review", "/api/market_intel/match_review_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_evidence_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_alert_plan", "/api/market_intel/migration_apply_drill", "/api/market_intel/migration_catalog_review", "/api/market_intel/migration_live_smoke", "/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_operator_drill", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_package", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_readiness", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_closeout", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_handoff", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_inventory", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_approval", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status")
+PRODUCTION_SMOKE_TARGETS = ("/health", "/market_intel", "/api/market_intel/status", "/api/market_intel/deployment_readiness", "/api/market_intel/schema_smoke", "/api/market_intel/schema_db_probe", "/api/market_intel/platform_seed_db_diff", "/api/market_intel/legacy_source_bridge", "/api/market_intel/mcp_readiness", "/api/market_intel/mcp_tool_contract", "/api/market_intel/mcp_deploy_preflight", "/api/market_intel/mcp_activation_runbook", "/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_gate", "/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review", "/api/market_intel/match_review_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_evidence_plan", "/api/market_intel/opportunity_alert_plan", "/api/market_intel/migration_apply_drill", "/api/market_intel/migration_catalog_review", "/api/market_intel/migration_live_smoke", "/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_operator_drill", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_package", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_readiness", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_writer_run_closeout", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_handoff", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_inventory", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_approval", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill", "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status")
 
 
 def _run_review_preview_safe(payload, mode):
@@ -126,6 +127,12 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(
         transaction_preview=candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction,
         execute_requested=False,
     )
+    candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill(
+        transaction_preview=candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction,
+        writer_preflight=candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight,
+        writer_status=candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status,
+        postwrite_smoke=candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke,
+    )
     checks = {
         "schema_smoke_passed": bool(schema_smoke["passed"]),
         "feature_flags_default_safe": bool(
@@ -372,6 +379,10 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(
             candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke,
             "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke_planned",
         ),
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview_safe": _run_review_preview_safe(
+            candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill,
+            "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview",
+        ),
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_status_safe": _run_review_preview_safe(
             candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status,
             "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_blocked",
@@ -610,6 +621,7 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction": candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction,
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight": candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight,
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke": candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke,
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill": candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill,
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status": candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status,
         "match_review_plan": match_review_plan,
         "opportunity_plan": opportunity_plan,

services/market_intel/phase.py

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 """市場情報 rollout phase 單一來源。"""
 
-MARKET_INTEL_PHASE = "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+MARKET_INTEL_PHASE = "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"

templates/market_intel/disabled.html

@@ -649,6 +649,9 @@
                 <button class="market-intel-icon-button" type="button" title="檢查 queue review decision writer post-write smoke" data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-postwrite-smoke>
                     <i class="fas fa-search" aria-hidden="true"></i>
                 </button>
+                <button class="market-intel-icon-button" type="button" title="產生 queue review decision writer operator drill" data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-operator-drill>
+                    <i class="fas fa-list-check" aria-hidden="true"></i>
+                </button>
                 <button class="market-intel-icon-button" type="button" title="檢查 queue review decision writer CLI gate" data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-writer>
                     <i class="fas fa-terminal" aria-hidden="true"></i>
                 </button>
@@ -996,6 +999,7 @@
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionTransaction = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-transaction]') : null;
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionPreflight = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-preflight]') : null;
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionPostwriteSmoke = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-postwrite-smoke]') : null;
+        const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrill = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-operator-drill]') : null;
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionWriter = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-writer]') : null;
         const sampleReviewEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel.market_intel_manual_sample_review') }}";
         const sampleReviewEvaluateEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel.market_intel_manual_sample_review_evaluate') }}";
@@ -1018,6 +1022,7 @@
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionTransactionEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel_review.market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction') }}";
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionPreflightEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel_review.market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight') }}";
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionPostwriteSmokeEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel_review.market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke') }}";
+        const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrillEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel_review.market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill') }}";
         const sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionWriterEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel_review.market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status') }}";
         const schedulerMeta = schedulerRoot ? schedulerRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-scheduler-meta]') : null;
         const schedulerBody = schedulerRoot ? schedulerRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-scheduler-body]') : null;
@@ -3854,6 +3859,113 @@
             }
         };
 
+        const renderCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrill = data => {
+            const blockers = (data.blocked_reasons || []).join(' / ');
+            const gates = data.gates || [];
+            const commands = data.command_sequence || [];
+            sampleReviewMeta.innerHTML = [
+                `mode=${data.mode || 'unknown'}`,
+                `ready=${data.operator_drill_ready ? 'yes' : 'no'}`,
+                `statements=${(data.statement_summary || {}).statement_count || 0}`,
+                `api_write=${data.api_updates_review_state ? 'yes' : 'no'}`
+            ].map(item => `<span class="market-intel-pill">${escapeHtml(item)}</span>`).join('');
+            sampleReviewBody.innerHTML = `
+                <div class="market-intel-empty mb-3">此卡只整理 review_state writer 的人工操作 drill；API/UI 不讀 token、不執行 CLI、不更新 review_state。${blockers ? `阻擋：${escapeHtml(blockers)}` : ''}</div>
+                <div class="market-intel-deploy-grid">
+                    <div>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">OPERATOR GATES</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            gates.map(gate => `
+                                <div class="market-intel-check">
+                                    <div>
+                                        <strong>${escapeHtml(gate.key)}</strong>
+                                        <small>${escapeHtml(gate.label)}</small>
+                                    </div>
+                                    <span>${gate.passed ? 'PASS' : 'BLOCK'}</span>
+                                </div>
+                            `).join('') || '<div class="market-intel-empty">尚未產生 drill gate。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">COMMAND ORDER</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            commands.map(command => `
+                                <div class="market-intel-check">
+                                    <div>
+                                        <strong>${escapeHtml(`${command.step}. ${command.key}`)}</strong>
+                                        <small>${escapeHtml(command.command_shape || '')}</small>
+                                    </div>
+                                    <span>${command.executes_database ? 'DB' : 'NO DB'}</span>
+                                </div>
+                            `).join('') || '<div class="market-intel-empty">尚未產生命令順序。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                </div>
+                <div class="market-intel-deploy-grid mt-3">
+                    <div>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">INPUTS</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            Object.entries(data.input_summaries || {}).map(([key, value]) => `
+                                <div class="market-intel-check">
+                                    <div><strong>${escapeHtml(key)}</strong></div>
+                                    <span>${escapeHtml(String(value))}</span>
+                                </div>
+                            `).join('') || '<div class="market-intel-empty">尚未提供輸入摘要。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">WRITE FLAGS</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">
+                            ${[
+                                ['api_executes_cli', data.api_executes_cli],
+                                ['api_reads_token', data.api_reads_approval_token],
+                                ['api_updates_review_state', data.api_updates_review_state],
+                                ['review_state_update_executed', data.review_state_update_executed],
+                                ['database_write', data.database_write_executed],
+                                ['scheduler', data.scheduler_attached]
+                            ].map(([key, value]) => `
+                                <div class="market-intel-check">
+                                    <div><strong>${escapeHtml(key)}</strong></div>
+                                    <span>${escapeHtml(String(value))}</span>
+                                </div>
+                            `).join('')}
+                        </div>
+                    </div>
+                </div>
+            `;
+        };
+
+        const loadCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrill = async () => {
+            if (!sampleReviewMeta || !sampleReviewBody || !sampleReviewInput) return;
+            let parsed;
+            try {
+                parsed = JSON.parse(sampleReviewInput.value || '{}');
+            } catch (error) {
+                sampleReviewMeta.innerHTML = '<span class="market-intel-pill">json_error</span>';
+                sampleReviewBody.innerHTML = `<div class="market-intel-empty">JSON 格式錯誤：${escapeHtml(error.message)}</div>`;
+                return;
+            }
+            const body = parsed && parsed.sample_result ? parsed : { sample_result: parsed };
+            sampleReviewBody.innerHTML = '<div class="market-intel-empty">產生 queue review decision writer operator drill 中...</div>';
+            try {
+                const response = await fetch(sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrillEndpoint, {
+                    method: 'POST',
+                    credentials: 'same-origin',
+                    headers: {
+                        'Content-Type': 'application/json',
+                        'X-CSRFToken': csrfToken
+                    },
+                    body: JSON.stringify(body)
+                });
+                const data = await response.json();
+                if (!response.ok && !data.mode) throw new Error(`HTTP ${response.status}`);
+                renderCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrill(data);
+            } catch (error) {
+                sampleReviewMeta.innerHTML = '<span class="market-intel-pill">error</span>';
+                sampleReviewBody.innerHTML = `<div class="market-intel-empty">queue review decision writer operator drill 失敗：${escapeHtml(error.message)}</div>`;
+            }
+        };
+
         const renderCandidateQueueReviewDecisionWriter = data => {
             const blockers = (data.blocked_reasons || []).join(' / ');
             const summary = data.statement_summary || {};
@@ -5518,6 +5630,9 @@
         if (sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionPostwriteSmoke) {
             sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionPostwriteSmoke.addEventListener('click', loadCandidateQueueReviewDecisionPostwriteSmoke);
         }
+        if (sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrill) {
+            sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrill.addEventListener('click', loadCandidateQueueReviewDecisionOperatorDrill);
+        }
         if (sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionWriter) {
             sampleCandidateQueueReviewDecisionWriter.addEventListener('click', loadCandidateQueueReviewDecisionWriter);
         }

tests/test_market_intel_skeleton.py

@@ -844,6 +844,10 @@ def test_market_intel_preview_template_uses_safe_fetch_false_endpoint():
         "market_intel_review.market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
         in template
     )
+    assert (
+        "market_intel_review.market_intel_manual_sample_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
+        in template
+    )
     assert (
         "data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-writer"
         in template
@@ -856,6 +860,10 @@ def test_market_intel_preview_template_uses_safe_fetch_false_endpoint():
         "data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-postwrite-smoke"
         in template
     )
+    assert (
+        "data-market-intel-sample-candidate-queue-review-decision-operator-drill"
+        in template
+    )
     assert "X-CSRFToken" in template
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_scheduler_plan" in template
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_match_review_plan" in template
@@ -892,7 +900,7 @@ def test_legacy_source_bridge_default_is_planned_only():
     bridge = MarketIntelService().build_legacy_source_bridge()
 
     assert bridge["mode"] == "legacy_source_bridge_planned"
-    assert bridge["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert bridge["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert bridge["execute_requested"] is False
     assert bridge["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert bridge["database_connection_opened"] is False
@@ -1050,7 +1058,7 @@ def test_mcp_tool_contract_preview_is_read_only_and_whitelisted():
     contract = MarketIntelService().build_mcp_tool_contract()
 
     assert contract["mode"] == "mcp_tool_contract_preview"
-    assert contract["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert contract["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert contract["caller"] == "market_intel"
     assert contract["contract_ready"] is True
     assert contract["blocked_reasons"] == []
@@ -1183,7 +1191,7 @@ def test_mcp_activation_runbook_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "mcp_activation_runbook_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["deployment_actions_executed"] is False
     assert data["docker_command_executed"] is False
     assert data["ssh_command_executed"] is False
@@ -1196,7 +1204,7 @@ def test_mcp_fetch_gate_default_blocks_external_fetch():
     gate = MarketIntelService().build_mcp_fetch_gate(fetch_requested=True)
 
     assert gate["mode"] == "mcp_fetch_gate_planned"
-    assert gate["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert gate["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert gate["fetch_requested"] is True
     assert gate["manual_fetch_gate_open"] is False
     assert gate["network_request_allowed"] is False
@@ -1266,7 +1274,7 @@ def test_mcp_fetch_gate_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "mcp_fetch_gate_planned"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["fetch_requested"] is False
     assert data["network_request_allowed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -1278,7 +1286,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_plan_preview_blocks_fetch_and_write():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "manual_sample_fetch_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert plan["ready_for_manual_sample_fetch"] is False
     assert plan["sample_fetch_executed"] is False
     assert plan["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -1326,7 +1334,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_fetch_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["sample_fetch_executed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
     assert data["database_write_executed"] is False
@@ -1337,7 +1345,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_acceptance_preview_blocks_candidate_import():
     acceptance = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_acceptance()
 
     assert acceptance["mode"] == "manual_sample_acceptance_preview"
-    assert acceptance["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert acceptance["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert acceptance["contract_ready"] is True
     assert acceptance["sample_result_loaded"] is False
     assert acceptance["sample_result_accepted"] is False
@@ -1379,7 +1387,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_acceptance_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_acceptance_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["sample_result_loaded"] is False
     assert data["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -1391,7 +1399,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_review_preview_is_planned_until_result_loaded():
     review = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_review()
 
     assert review["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_preview"
-    assert review["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert review["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert review["contract_ready"] is True
     assert review["sample_result_loaded"] is False
     assert review["sample_result_reviewed"] is False
@@ -1502,7 +1510,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_review_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["sample_result_loaded"] is False
     assert data["sample_result_reviewed"] is False
     assert data["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
@@ -1541,7 +1549,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_review_evaluation_preview_accepts_payload_without_persist
     )
 
     assert review["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_evaluation_preview"
-    assert review["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert review["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert review["review_request_type"] == "operator_posted_json"
     assert review["payload_received"] is True
     assert review["payload_valid_json_object"] is True
@@ -1603,7 +1611,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_review_evaluate_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_evaluation_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["payload_received"] is True
     assert data["payload_valid_json_object"] is True
     assert data["payload_persisted"] is False
@@ -1683,7 +1691,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_handoff_preview_creates_candidates_without_pers
     )
 
     assert handoff["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_handoff_preview"
-    assert handoff["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert handoff["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert handoff["payload_received"] is True
     assert handoff["payload_valid_json_object"] is True
     assert handoff["payload_persisted"] is False
@@ -1747,7 +1755,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_handoff_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_handoff_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["payload_received"] is True
     assert data["handoff_ready"] is True
     assert data["candidate_handoff_created"] is True
@@ -1806,7 +1814,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_queue_draft_preview_builds_review_items_without
     )
 
     assert queue_draft["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_queue_draft_preview"
-    assert queue_draft["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert queue_draft["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert queue_draft["payload_received"] is True
     assert queue_draft["payload_valid_json_object"] is True
     assert queue_draft["payload_persisted"] is False
@@ -1880,7 +1888,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_queue_draft_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_queue_draft_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["payload_received"] is True
     assert data["handoff_ready"] is True
     assert data["queue_draft_ready"] is True
@@ -1943,7 +1951,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_queue_approval_preview_blocks_write_and_maps_ro
     )
 
     assert approval["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_queue_approval_preview"
-    assert approval["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert approval["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert approval["payload_received"] is True
     assert approval["payload_valid_json_object"] is True
     assert approval["payload_persisted"] is False
@@ -2021,7 +2029,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_queue_approval_route_is_post_only_and_no_write(
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_queue_approval_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["payload_received"] is True
     assert data["approval_preview_created"] is True
     assert data["approval_request_created"] is False
@@ -2084,7 +2092,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_queue_transaction_preview_blocks_execution():
     )
 
     assert transaction["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_queue_transaction_preview"
-    assert transaction["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert transaction["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert transaction["payload_received"] is True
     assert transaction["payload_valid_json_object"] is True
     assert transaction["payload_persisted"] is False
@@ -2164,7 +2172,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_candidate_queue_transaction_route_is_post_only_and_no_wri
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_candidate_queue_transaction_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["payload_received"] is True
     assert data["transaction_preview_created"] is True
     assert data["transaction_ready"] is False
@@ -4069,6 +4077,99 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke_is_read_only():
     assert TEST_APPROVAL_TOKEN not in payload
 
 
+def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview_is_safe():
+    from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli import (
+        build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_plan,
+    )
+    from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight import (
+        build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight,
+    )
+    from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke import (
+        build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke,
+    )
+    from services.market_intel.candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill import (
+        build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill,
+    )
+
+    transaction, operator_evidence = _build_ready_review_decision_transaction()
+    operator_evidence = {
+        **operator_evidence,
+        "operator_confirmed_manual_shell_window": True,
+        "operator_confirmed_post_update_inventory_planned": True,
+        "operator_drill_notes": "review_state shell drill reviewed",
+    }
+    writer_status = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_plan(
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+    )
+    preflight = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight(
+        writer_status=writer_status,
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+    )
+    smoke = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke(
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        execute_requested=False,
+    )
+    drill = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill(
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        writer_preflight=preflight,
+        writer_status=writer_status,
+        postwrite_smoke=smoke,
+        operator_evidence=operator_evidence,
+    )
+    token_leak = build_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill(
+        transaction_preview=transaction,
+        writer_preflight=preflight,
+        writer_status=writer_status,
+        postwrite_smoke=smoke,
+        operator_evidence={**operator_evidence, "approval_token": TEST_APPROVAL_TOKEN},
+    )
+    payload = json.dumps(drill, ensure_ascii=False, sort_keys=True)
+
+    assert drill["mode"] == (
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview"
+    )
+    assert drill["target_table"] == "market_alert_review_queue"
+    assert drill["target_operation"] == "update_review_state"
+    assert drill["operator_drill_ready"] is True
+    assert drill["ready_for_api_review_state_update"] is False
+    assert drill["ready_for_api_database_write"] is False
+    assert drill["ready_for_scheduler_attach"] is False
+    assert drill["api_executes_cli"] is False
+    assert drill["api_reads_approval_token"] is False
+    assert drill["api_writes_file"] is False
+    assert drill["api_writes_database"] is False
+    assert drill["api_updates_review_state"] is False
+    assert drill["review_state_update_executed"] is False
+    assert drill["database_connection_opened"] is False
+    assert drill["database_session_created"] is False
+    assert drill["transaction_opened"] is False
+    assert drill["transaction_committed"] is False
+    assert drill["database_write_executed"] is False
+    assert drill["database_commit_executed"] is False
+    assert drill["scheduler_attached"] is False
+    assert drill["statement_summary"]["statement_count"] == 1
+    assert drill["statement_summary"]["invalid_statement_count"] == 0
+    assert drill["input_summaries"]["writer_preflight_mode"] == (
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight_preview"
+    )
+    assert drill["input_summaries"]["postwrite_smoke_mode"] == (
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke_planned"
+    )
+    assert len(drill["command_sequence"]) == 5
+    assert any(item["key"] == "run_cli_review_state_writer" for item in drill["command_sequence"])
+    assert "backup_verified_by_operator" in drill["blocked_reasons"]
+    assert "do_not_update_review_state_from_review_state_operator_drill" in drill[
+        "safe_boundaries"
+    ]
+    assert token_leak["operator_drill_ready"] is False
+    assert "operator_drill_no_token_submitted_to_api" in token_leak[
+        "blocked_reasons"
+    ]
+    assert TEST_APPROVAL_TOKEN not in payload
+
+
 def test_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
     from routes.market_intel_routes import market_intel_bp
 
@@ -4111,7 +4212,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_preflight_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_preflight_planned"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert data["database_connection_opened"] is False
@@ -4168,7 +4269,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_status_route_never_leaks_approval_token(monkeypa
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_cli_blocked"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is True
     assert data["apply_real_write_requested"] is True
     assert data["approval_token_present"] is False
@@ -4257,7 +4358,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke_route_is_post_only_and_no_write(
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_postwrite_smoke_planned"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert data["database_connection_opened"] is False
@@ -4311,7 +4412,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_operator_drill_route_is_post_only_and_no_write()
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_operator_drill_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["operator_drill_ready"] is True
     assert data["api_executes_cli"] is False
     assert data["api_reads_approval_token"] is False
@@ -4367,7 +4468,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_run_package_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_run_package_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["package_ready"] is True
     assert data["package_artifact_created"] is False
     assert data["api_writes_file"] is False
@@ -4433,7 +4534,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_run_readiness_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_run_readiness_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["ready_for_cli_operator_run"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_api_database_write"] is False
     assert data["api_executes_cli"] is False
@@ -4735,7 +4836,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt_route_accepts_inline_payload_no_writ
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["receipt_passed"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_api_database_write"] is False
     assert data["ready_for_scheduler_attach"] is False
@@ -4783,7 +4884,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_run_closeout_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_run_closeout_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["closeout_passed"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_next_manual_phase"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_api_database_write"] is False
@@ -4832,7 +4933,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_handoff_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_review_handoff_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["handoff_ready"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_manual_queue_review"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_api_database_write"] is False
@@ -4890,7 +4991,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_inventory_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
     assert get_response.status_code == 405
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_review_inventory_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["review_inventory_ready"] is False
     assert data["ready_for_human_decision_review"] is False
@@ -4956,7 +5057,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
     assert get_response.status_code == 405
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_review_decision_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["decision_ready"] is False
     assert data["ready_for_human_decision_record"] is False
     assert data["ready_for_api_review_state_update"] is False
@@ -5027,7 +5128,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_approval_route_is_post_only_and_no_writ
     assert get_response.status_code == 405
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_review_decision_approval_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["approval_ready"] is False
     assert data["ready_for_review_state_transaction_preview"] is False
     assert data["ready_for_cli_decision_writer"] is False
@@ -5103,7 +5204,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction_route_is_post_only_and_no_w
     assert get_response.status_code == 405
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_review_decision_transaction_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["transaction_preview_created"] is False
     assert data["transaction_ready"] is False
     assert data["ready_for_manual_shell_update_window"] is False
@@ -5185,7 +5286,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status_route_is_post_only_and_no
     assert get_response.status_code == 405
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_blocked"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is True
     assert data["apply_real_write_requested"] is True
     assert data["approval_token_present"] is False
@@ -5271,7 +5372,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight_route_is_post_only_and
     assert data["mode"] == (
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_preflight_preview"
     )
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is True
     assert data["apply_real_write_requested"] is True
     assert data["read_only_query_executed"] is False
@@ -5354,7 +5455,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke_route_is_post_on
     assert data["mode"] == (
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke_planned"
     )
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert data["database_connection_opened"] is False
@@ -5379,6 +5480,92 @@ def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke_route_is_post_on
     ]
 
 
+def test_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
+    from routes.market_intel_routes import market_intel_bp
+    from routes.market_intel_review_routes import market_intel_review_bp
+
+    fixture = _build_candidate_queue_writer_receipt_fixture(
+        "sample-batch-review-decision-operator-drill-route"
+    )
+    app = Flask(__name__)
+    app.secret_key = "test-secret"
+    app.register_blueprint(market_intel_bp)
+    app.register_blueprint(market_intel_review_bp)
+    client = app.test_client()
+    with client.session_transaction() as session:
+        session["logged_in"] = True
+
+    get_response = client.get(
+        "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/"
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
+    )
+    response = client.post(
+        "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/"
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill",
+        json={
+            "sample_result": fixture["sample_result"],
+            "operator_evidence": {
+                **fixture["operator_evidence"],
+                "closeout_artifact_path": "artifacts/market_intel/closeout.json",
+                "operator_confirmed_queue_review_next": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_no_scheduler_attach": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_no_api_db_write": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_inventory_read_only": True,
+                "reviewer_id": "operator-a",
+                "proposed_review_decision": "confirmed",
+                "decision_notes": "manual review only",
+                "operator_confirmed_manual_decision_only": True,
+                "decision_approval_notes": "cli-only approval gate",
+                "operator_confirmed_decision_payload_reviewed": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_decision_apply_requires_cli": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_review_state_update_is_not_api": True,
+                "decision_transaction_notes": "shell-only transaction preview",
+                "operator_confirmed_transaction_payload_reviewed": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_cli_only_transaction": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_manual_shell_window": True,
+                "operator_confirmed_post_update_inventory_planned": True,
+                "operator_drill_notes": "manual shell drill reviewed",
+            },
+            "writer_output": fixture["writer_output"],
+            "postwrite_smoke_result": fixture["postwrite_smoke_result"],
+        },
+    )
+    data = response.get_json()
+    payload = json.dumps(data, ensure_ascii=False, sort_keys=True)
+
+    assert get_response.status_code == 405
+    assert response.status_code == 200
+    assert data["mode"] == (
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview"
+    )
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
+    assert data["operator_drill_ready"] is False
+    assert data["ready_for_api_review_state_update"] is False
+    assert data["ready_for_api_database_write"] is False
+    assert data["ready_for_scheduler_attach"] is False
+    assert data["api_executes_cli"] is False
+    assert data["api_reads_approval_token"] is False
+    assert data["api_writes_file"] is False
+    assert data["api_writes_database"] is False
+    assert data["api_updates_review_state"] is False
+    assert data["database_connection_opened"] is False
+    assert data["database_write_executed"] is False
+    assert data["database_commit_executed"] is False
+    assert data["review_state_update_executed"] is False
+    assert data["scheduler_attached"] is False
+    assert data["statement_summary"]["statement_count"] == 0
+    assert data["input_summaries"]["writer_status_mode"] == (
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_blocked"
+    )
+    assert "transaction_preview_created" in data["blocked_reasons"]
+    assert "transaction_has_update_statements" in data["blocked_reasons"]
+    assert "backup_verified_by_operator" in data["blocked_reasons"]
+    assert "do_not_execute_review_state_writer_from_operator_drill_api" in data[
+        "safe_boundaries"
+    ]
+    assert TEST_APPROVAL_TOKEN not in payload
+
+
 def test_candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
     from routes.market_intel_routes import market_intel_bp
 
@@ -5407,7 +5594,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt_route_is_post_only_and_no_write():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_run_receipt_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["receipt_passed"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_next_manual_review"] is True
     assert data["ready_for_api_database_write"] is False
@@ -5432,7 +5619,7 @@ def test_scheduler_plan_preview_blocks_job_attachment():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_scheduler_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "scheduler_attach_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert plan["ready_to_attach_scheduler"] is False
     assert plan["scheduler_attached"] is False
     assert plan["scheduler_registration_executed"] is False
@@ -5470,7 +5657,7 @@ def test_scheduler_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "scheduler_attach_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["scheduler_registration_executed"] is False
     assert data["crawler_job_started"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -5481,7 +5668,7 @@ def test_match_review_plan_preview_blocks_auto_confirm():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_match_review_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "match_review_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert plan["ready_for_review_queue"] is False
     assert plan["review_queue_created"] is False
     assert plan["auto_match_executed"] is False
@@ -5517,7 +5704,7 @@ def test_match_review_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "match_review_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["review_queue_created"] is False
     assert data["auto_confirm_executed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -5528,7 +5715,7 @@ def test_opportunity_plan_preview_blocks_alerts_and_ai_summary():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert plan["ready_for_opportunity_queue"] is False
     assert plan["opportunity_queue_created"] is False
     assert plan["threat_alert_dispatched"] is False
@@ -5569,7 +5756,7 @@ def test_opportunity_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["opportunity_queue_created"] is False
     assert data["threat_alert_dispatched"] is False
     assert data["ai_summary_generated"] is False
@@ -5580,7 +5767,7 @@ def test_opportunity_scoring_plan_preview_blocks_scoring_and_alerts():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_scoring_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_scoring_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert plan["ready_for_scoring_job"] is False
     assert plan["scoring_job_created"] is False
     assert plan["score_calculation_executed"] is False
@@ -5628,7 +5815,7 @@ def test_opportunity_scoring_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_scoring_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["scoring_job_created"] is False
     assert data["score_calculation_executed"] is False
     assert data["sample_scores_generated"] is False
@@ -5640,7 +5827,7 @@ def test_opportunity_evidence_plan_preview_blocks_queries_and_alerts():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_evidence_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_evidence_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert plan["ready_for_evidence_bundle"] is False
     assert plan["evidence_bundle_created"] is False
     assert plan["evidence_query_executed"] is False
@@ -5686,7 +5873,7 @@ def test_opportunity_evidence_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_evidence_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["evidence_bundle_created"] is False
     assert data["evidence_query_executed"] is False
     assert data["sample_evidence_generated"] is False
@@ -5699,7 +5886,7 @@ def test_opportunity_alert_plan_preview_blocks_dispatch_and_llm_calls():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_alert_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_alert_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert plan["ready_for_alert_candidates"] is False
     assert plan["alert_candidate_created"] is False
     assert plan["alert_queue_created"] is False
@@ -5784,7 +5971,7 @@ def test_opportunity_alert_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_alert_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["alert_candidate_created"] is False
     assert data["alert_queue_created"] is False
     assert data["review_queue_created"] is False
@@ -5862,7 +6049,7 @@ def test_mcp_deploy_preflight_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "mcp_external_deploy_preflight_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["deployment_actions_executed"] is False
     assert data["docker_command_executed"] is False
     assert data["ssh_command_executed"] is False
@@ -5877,7 +6064,7 @@ def test_mcp_readiness_default_is_planned_only(monkeypatch):
     readiness = MarketIntelService().build_mcp_readiness()
 
     assert readiness["mode"] == "mcp_readiness_planned"
-    assert readiness["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert readiness["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert readiness["execute_requested"] is False
     assert readiness["router_enabled"] is False
     assert readiness["external_mcp_complete"] is False
@@ -6335,6 +6522,12 @@ def test_deployment_readiness_reports_app_only_release_gate():
         ]
         is True
     )
+    assert (
+        readiness["checks"][
+            "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview_safe"
+        ]
+        is True
+    )
     assert (
         readiness["checks"][
             "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_status_safe"
@@ -6439,6 +6632,11 @@ def test_deployment_readiness_reports_app_only_release_gate():
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
         in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
     )
+    assert (
+        "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/"
+        "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
+        in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
+    )
     assert (
         "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review/"
         "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status"
@@ -7328,6 +7526,58 @@ def test_deployment_readiness_reports_app_only_release_gate():
         ]
         is False
     )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"]["mode"]
+        == "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill_preview"
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "api_executes_cli"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "api_reads_approval_token"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "api_updates_review_state"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "database_connection_opened"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "database_write_executed"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "database_commit_executed"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "review_state_update_executed"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
+    assert (
+        readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"][
+            "scheduler_attached"
+        ]
+        is False
+    )
     assert (
         readiness["candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_status"]["mode"]
         == "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_blocked"
@@ -7478,7 +7728,7 @@ def test_migration_apply_drill_planned_is_safe_and_manual_only():
     drill = MarketIntelService().build_migration_apply_drill()
 
     assert drill["mode"] == "migration_apply_drill_preview"
-    assert drill["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert drill["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert drill["execute_requested"] is False
     assert drill["schema_state"] == "planned_no_db_probe"
     assert drill["drill_ready_for_operator_review"] is True
@@ -7593,7 +7843,7 @@ def test_migration_apply_drill_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "migration_apply_drill_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["migration_executed"] is False
     assert data["rollback_executed"] is False
@@ -7605,7 +7855,7 @@ def test_migration_catalog_review_planned_is_safe_and_diagnostic():
     review = MarketIntelService().build_migration_catalog_review()
 
     assert review["mode"] == "migration_catalog_review_preview"
-    assert review["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert review["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert review["execute_requested"] is False
     assert review["catalog_state"] == "planned_no_probe"
     assert review["seed_state"] == "planned_no_probe"
@@ -7720,7 +7970,7 @@ def test_migration_catalog_review_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "migration_catalog_review_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["catalog_state"] == "planned_no_probe"
     assert data["migration_executed"] is False
@@ -7733,7 +7983,7 @@ def test_migration_live_smoke_planned_is_preview_only():
     smoke = MarketIntelService().build_migration_live_smoke()
 
     assert smoke["mode"] == "migration_live_smoke_preview"
-    assert smoke["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert smoke["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert smoke["execute_requested"] is False
     assert smoke["smoke_result"] == "planned_no_execution"
     assert smoke["live_smoke_passed"] is False
@@ -7795,7 +8045,7 @@ def test_migration_live_smoke_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "migration_live_smoke_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["smoke_result"] == "planned_no_execution"
     assert data["migration_executed"] is False
@@ -7808,7 +8058,7 @@ def test_live_db_inventory_planned_is_preview_only():
     inventory = MarketIntelService().build_live_db_inventory()
 
     assert inventory["mode"] == "live_db_inventory_planned"
-    assert inventory["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert inventory["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert inventory["execute_requested"] is False
     assert inventory["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert inventory["database_connection_opened"] is False
@@ -7952,7 +8202,7 @@ def test_live_db_inventory_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "live_db_inventory_planned"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert data["database_write_executed"] is False
@@ -8179,7 +8429,7 @@ def test_candidate_queue_writer_cli_script_outputs_blocked_gate(tmp_path):
 
     assert result.returncode == 0
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_writer_cli_blocked"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["apply_real_write_requested"] is False
     assert data["writes_executed"] is False
@@ -8208,7 +8458,7 @@ def test_review_decision_writer_cli_script_outputs_blocked_gate_without_login_en
 
     assert result.returncode == 0
     assert data["mode"] == "candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_cli_blocked"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_71_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_postwrite_smoke"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_72_candidate_queue_review_decision_writer_operator_drill"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["apply_real_write_requested"] is False
     assert data["approval_token_present"] is False