新增市場情報樣本結果審核預覽

TODO_NEXT_STEPS.txt

@@ -102,6 +102,7 @@
    - Phase 46 live DB inventory preview：新增 `/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory` 與 UI「正式 DB 庫存總覽」panel；預設 `execute=false` 不連 DB，人工 smoke 才可用 `execute=true` 對 `market_*` tables 做只讀 count / group by，建立平台、活動、商品、比對、告警與 crawler run 基準；版本同步至 V10.209。
    - Phase 47 manual sample fetch plan：新增 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan` 與 UI「人工樣本 Fetch 計畫」panel；預設只輸出平台順序、每平台 1 個公開入口、MCP gate、操作員步驟與備援，不抓外站、不寫 DB、不建立 crawler run、不掛 scheduler；版本同步至 V10.214。
    - Phase 48 manual sample acceptance contract：新增 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance` 與 UI「樣本結果驗收契約」panel；定義 sample result 必要欄位、diagnostics 欄位、驗收門檻、拒收條件、人工決策與升級順序，不載入 sample result、不抓外站、不允許候選導入、不寫 DB；版本同步至 V10.215。
+   - Phase 49 manual sample result review：新增 `services/market_intel/manual_sample_review.py`、`/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review` 與 UI「樣本結果審核預覽」panel；以純函式評估人工 sample result 是否可進候選預覽，預設不載入結果、不抓外站、不存檔、不寫 DB、不允許候選導入、不掛 scheduler；版本同步至 V10.216。
    - Schema smoke：`tests/test_market_intel_skeleton.py` 檢查 `Base.metadata` 內含 ADR-035 八張 `market_*` tables。
    - Desktop UI QA：本機只註冊 `market_intel_bp` 的 Flask harness 載入 `/market_intel`，確認 Phase 15、候選預覽、writer preview、安全 flags、點陣暖紙視覺正常，console error 0。
    - API QA：`/api/market_intel/schema_smoke` 通過 7 張表與 `market_platforms` 必要欄位檢查；`/api/market_intel/platform_seed_writer_plan` 回傳 4 筆 dry-run upsert preview，`writes_executed=false`，四平台皆 `blocked_dry_run_only`。

docs/adr/ADR-035-cross-platform-market-campaign-intelligence.md

@@ -174,6 +174,7 @@ EwoooC 目前已有 MOMO EDM / 節慶活動資料、`promo_products`、PChome
 - 2026-05-18 追加 live DB inventory preview：`services.market_intel.live_db_inventory` 與 `/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory` 預設 `execute=false` 只回 planned，不連 DB；人工 smoke 可用 `execute=true` 對 `market_*` tables 執行只讀 count / group by，產生平台、活動狀態、商品活躍度、比對狀態、告警審核佇列與 crawler run 基準總覽。此探針不建立 ORM session、不寫 DB、不執行 migration、不連外、不掛 scheduler。
 - 2026-05-19 追加 manual sample fetch plan preview：`services.market_intel.manual_sample_plan` 與 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan` 定義第一次人工 sample fetch 的平台順序、每平台 1 個公開入口、MCP fetch gate、正式 DB 庫存基準、操作員步驟與備援。此階段只產生計畫，不抓外部網站、不寫 DB、不建立 crawler run、不掛 scheduler、不繞反爬。
 - 2026-05-19 追加 manual sample acceptance contract：`services.market_intel.manual_sample_acceptance` 與 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance` 定義 sample fetch 結果回來後的必要欄位、診斷欄位、驗收門檻、拒收條件、人工決策與升級順序。此階段不載入 sample result、不抓外部網站、不允許候選導入、不寫 DB、不掛 scheduler。
+- 2026-05-19 追加 manual sample result review：`services.market_intel.manual_sample_review` 與 `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review` 以純函式評估操作員提供的 sample result 是否通過 Phase 48 驗收門檻並可進候選預覽。API/UI 預設不載入 sample result，不抓外站、不存檔、不寫 DB、不允許候選導入、不掛 scheduler；即使審核通過也只開 candidate preview gate，正式 market_* 寫入仍需後續獨立批准。
 
 ### Phase 4：Coupang / Shopee Adapter
 

routes/README.md

@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@
 | `edm_routes.py` | EDM 與節慶儀表板 | `/edm`, `/festival` |
 | `monthly_routes.py` | 月結分析 | `/monthly_summary_analysis`, `/api/monthly_summary_data` |
 | `daily_sales_routes.py` | 當日業績 | `/daily_sales`, `/daily_sales/export*` |
-| `market_intel_routes.py` | 市場情報 Phase 48 manual sample acceptance contract | `/market_intel`, `/market_intel/*`, `/api/market_intel/status`, `/api/market_intel/schema`, `/api/market_intel/schema_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/schema_db_probe`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_db_diff`, `/api/market_intel/legacy_source_bridge`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_readiness`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_tool_contract`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_deploy_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_activation_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_gate`, `/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance`, `/api/market_intel/match_review_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_evidence_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_alert_plan`, `/api/market_intel/adapters`, `/api/market_intel/dry_run_plan`, `/api/market_intel/discovery_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_discovery`, `/api/market_intel/candidate_preview`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_plan`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_write_guard`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_writer_plan`, `/api/market_intel/migration_blueprint`, `/api/market_intel/migration_apply_drill`, `/api/market_intel/migration_catalog_review`, `/api/market_intel/migration_live_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory`, `/api/market_intel/seed_writer_cli_status`, `/api/market_intel/write_approval_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/deployment_readiness` |
+| `market_intel_routes.py` | 市場情報 Phase 49 manual sample result review | `/market_intel`, `/market_intel/*`, `/api/market_intel/status`, `/api/market_intel/schema`, `/api/market_intel/schema_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/schema_db_probe`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_db_diff`, `/api/market_intel/legacy_source_bridge`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_readiness`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_tool_contract`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_deploy_preflight`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_activation_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/mcp_fetch_gate`, `/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance`, `/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review`, `/api/market_intel/match_review_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_evidence_plan`, `/api/market_intel/opportunity_alert_plan`, `/api/market_intel/adapters`, `/api/market_intel/dry_run_plan`, `/api/market_intel/discovery_plan`, `/api/market_intel/manual_discovery`, `/api/market_intel/candidate_preview`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_plan`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_write_guard`, `/api/market_intel/platform_seed_writer_plan`, `/api/market_intel/migration_blueprint`, `/api/market_intel/migration_apply_drill`, `/api/market_intel/migration_catalog_review`, `/api/market_intel/migration_live_smoke`, `/api/market_intel/live_db_inventory`, `/api/market_intel/seed_writer_cli_status`, `/api/market_intel/write_approval_runbook`, `/api/market_intel/deployment_readiness` |
 | `api_routes.py` | 通用任務與查詢 API | `/api/run_task`, `/api/history/*` |
 | `export_routes.py` | 匯出功能 | `/api/export/*` |
 | `import_routes.py` | 匯入功能 | `/api/import_excel`, `/api/import/monthly_summary` |

routes/market_intel_routes.py

@@ -169,6 +169,12 @@ def market_intel_manual_sample_acceptance():
     return jsonify(_service().build_manual_sample_acceptance())
 
 
+@market_intel_bp.route("/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review")
+@login_required
+def market_intel_manual_sample_review():
+    return jsonify(_service().build_manual_sample_review())
+
+
 @market_intel_bp.route("/api/market_intel/match_review_plan")
 @login_required
 def market_intel_match_review_plan():

services/market_intel/deployment_readiness.py

@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(
     scheduler_plan = service.build_scheduler_plan()
     manual_sample_plan = service.build_manual_sample_plan()
     manual_sample_acceptance = service.build_manual_sample_acceptance()
+    manual_sample_review = service.build_manual_sample_review()
     match_review_plan = service.build_match_review_plan()
     opportunity_plan = service.build_opportunity_plan()
     opportunity_scoring_plan = service.build_opportunity_scoring_plan()
@@ -96,6 +97,15 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(
             and not manual_sample_acceptance["database_commit_executed"]
             and not manual_sample_acceptance["scheduler_attached"]
         ),
+        "manual_sample_review_preview_safe": bool(
+            manual_sample_review["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_preview"
+            and not manual_sample_review["sample_result_loaded"]
+            and not manual_sample_review["candidate_import_allowed"]
+            and not manual_sample_review["external_network_executed"]
+            and not manual_sample_review["database_write_executed"]
+            and not manual_sample_review["database_commit_executed"]
+            and not manual_sample_review["scheduler_attached"]
+        ),
         "match_review_plan_preview_safe": bool(
             match_review_plan["mode"] == "match_review_plan_preview"
             and not match_review_plan["review_queue_created"]
@@ -300,6 +310,7 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(
             "/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan",
             "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan",
             "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance",
+            "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review",
             "/api/market_intel/match_review_plan",
             "/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan",
             "/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan",
@@ -335,6 +346,7 @@ def build_deployment_readiness_preview(
         "scheduler_plan": scheduler_plan,
         "manual_sample_plan": manual_sample_plan,
         "manual_sample_acceptance": manual_sample_acceptance,
+        "manual_sample_review": manual_sample_review,
         "match_review_plan": match_review_plan,
         "opportunity_plan": opportunity_plan,
         "opportunity_scoring_plan": opportunity_scoring_plan,

services/market_intel/manual_sample_review.py

@@ -0,0 +1,297 @@
+"""市場情報人工 sample result 審核預覽。
+
+本模組只用純函式評估操作員提供的 sample result payload；
+不抓外部網站、不查 DB、不寫 DB、不建立候選活動、不掛排程。
+"""
+
+from services.market_intel.manual_sample_acceptance import (
+    REQUIRED_DIAGNOSTIC_FIELDS,
+    REQUIRED_RESULT_FIELDS,
+)
+
+
+DEFAULT_ACCEPTANCE_THRESHOLDS = {
+    "http_status_min": 200,
+    "http_status_max": 299,
+    "minimum_content_length": 500,
+    "page_hash_length": 64,
+    "minimum_title_length": 2,
+    "minimum_link_count": 1,
+    "minimum_campaign_candidates": 1,
+    "accepted_candidate_bands": ["high", "medium"],
+}
+
+
+def _as_int(value, default=0):
+    try:
+        return int(value)
+    except (TypeError, ValueError):
+        return default
+
+
+def _thresholds(acceptance_contract):
+    configured = {}
+    if isinstance(acceptance_contract, dict):
+        configured = acceptance_contract.get("acceptance_thresholds") or {}
+    return {
+        **DEFAULT_ACCEPTANCE_THRESHOLDS,
+        **configured,
+    }
+
+
+def _normalize_candidate(candidate):
+    if not isinstance(candidate, dict):
+        return {
+            "confidence_band": "unknown",
+            "score": 0,
+            "url": "",
+            "text": "",
+        }
+    return {
+        "confidence_band": str(candidate.get("confidence_band") or "unknown"),
+        "score": _as_int(candidate.get("score"), 0),
+        "url": str(candidate.get("url") or candidate.get("href") or ""),
+        "text": str(candidate.get("text") or candidate.get("title") or ""),
+    }
+
+
+def _build_check(key, label, passed, observed, expected):
+    return {
+        "key": key,
+        "label": label,
+        "status": "pass" if passed else "block",
+        "passed": bool(passed),
+        "observed": observed,
+        "expected": expected,
+    }
+
+
+def evaluate_manual_sample_result(sample_result, acceptance_contract):
+    """以驗收契約評估單一 sample result；不做任何 IO。"""
+    thresholds = _thresholds(acceptance_contract)
+    if not sample_result:
+        return {
+            "sample_result_loaded": False,
+            "sample_result_reviewed": False,
+            "sample_result_accepted": False,
+            "ready_for_candidate_preview": False,
+            "candidate_import_allowed": False,
+            "review_result": "planned_no_sample_result",
+            "review_checks": [],
+            "review_findings": [
+                {
+                    "key": "sample_result_not_loaded",
+                    "severity": "block",
+                    "label": "尚未載入人工樣本結果，維持預覽狀態",
+                },
+            ],
+            "candidate_summary": {
+                "candidate_count": 0,
+                "accepted_candidate_count": 0,
+                "accepted_candidate_bands": thresholds["accepted_candidate_bands"],
+                "top_candidates": [],
+            },
+        }
+
+    diagnostics = sample_result.get("diagnostics")
+    diagnostics = diagnostics if isinstance(diagnostics, dict) else {}
+    candidates = diagnostics.get("campaign_link_candidates")
+    candidates = candidates if isinstance(candidates, list) else []
+    normalized_candidates = [_normalize_candidate(item) for item in candidates]
+    accepted_bands = set(thresholds["accepted_candidate_bands"])
+    accepted_candidates = [
+        item for item in normalized_candidates
+        if item["confidence_band"] in accepted_bands
+    ]
+
+    missing_result_fields = [
+        field for field in REQUIRED_RESULT_FIELDS
+        if sample_result.get(field) in (None, "")
+    ]
+    missing_diagnostic_fields = [
+        field for field in REQUIRED_DIAGNOSTIC_FIELDS
+        if diagnostics.get(field) in (None, "")
+    ]
+    status_code = _as_int(sample_result.get("status_code"), 0)
+    content_length = _as_int(sample_result.get("content_length"), 0)
+    page_hash = str(sample_result.get("page_hash") or "")
+    title = str(sample_result.get("title") or "")
+    link_count = _as_int(diagnostics.get("link_count"), 0)
+
+    checks = [
+        _build_check(
+            "required_result_fields_present",
+            "sample result 必須包含 Phase 48 定義的必要欄位",
+            not missing_result_fields,
+            missing_result_fields,
+            list(REQUIRED_RESULT_FIELDS),
+        ),
+        _build_check(
+            "required_diagnostics_present",
+            "diagnostics 必須包含連結與候選診斷欄位",
+            not missing_diagnostic_fields,
+            missing_diagnostic_fields,
+            list(REQUIRED_DIAGNOSTIC_FIELDS),
+        ),
+        _build_check(
+            "http_status_ok",
+            "HTTP status 必須落在允收區間",
+            thresholds["http_status_min"]
+            <= status_code
+            <= thresholds["http_status_max"],
+            status_code,
+            f"{thresholds['http_status_min']}-{thresholds['http_status_max']}",
+        ),
+        _build_check(
+            "content_has_body",
+            "content_length 必須超過最低門檻",
+            content_length >= thresholds["minimum_content_length"],
+            content_length,
+            thresholds["minimum_content_length"],
+        ),
+        _build_check(
+            "page_fingerprint_present",
+            "page_hash 必須符合固定長度，後續才能比對頁面變化",
+            len(page_hash) == thresholds["page_hash_length"],
+            len(page_hash),
+            thresholds["page_hash_length"],
+        ),
+        _build_check(
+            "title_present",
+            "title 必須能判斷頁面內容，不接受空白或挑戰頁",
+            len(title.strip()) >= thresholds["minimum_title_length"],
+            len(title.strip()),
+            thresholds["minimum_title_length"],
+        ),
+        _build_check(
+            "link_count_present",
+            "link_count 必須高於最低門檻，避免空頁或驗證頁",
+            link_count >= thresholds["minimum_link_count"],
+            link_count,
+            thresholds["minimum_link_count"],
+        ),
+        _build_check(
+            "candidate_quality_reviewed",
+            "至少需要一筆 high/medium 活動候選進入人工候選預覽",
+            len(accepted_candidates) >= thresholds["minimum_campaign_candidates"],
+            len(accepted_candidates),
+            thresholds["minimum_campaign_candidates"],
+        ),
+    ]
+    findings = [
+        {
+            "key": check["key"],
+            "severity": "block",
+            "label": check["label"],
+            "observed": check["observed"],
+            "expected": check["expected"],
+        }
+        for check in checks
+        if not check["passed"]
+    ]
+    accepted = all(check["passed"] for check in checks)
+    return {
+        "sample_result_loaded": True,
+        "sample_result_reviewed": True,
+        "sample_result_accepted": accepted,
+        "ready_for_candidate_preview": accepted,
+        "candidate_import_allowed": False,
+        "review_result": (
+            "accepted_for_candidate_preview"
+            if accepted
+            else "rejected_sample_result"
+        ),
+        "review_checks": checks,
+        "review_findings": findings,
+        "candidate_summary": {
+            "candidate_count": len(normalized_candidates),
+            "accepted_candidate_count": len(accepted_candidates),
+            "accepted_candidate_bands": thresholds["accepted_candidate_bands"],
+            "top_candidates": accepted_candidates[:5],
+        },
+    }
+
+
+def build_manual_sample_review_preview(
+    *,
+    runtime_status,
+    acceptance_contract,
+    sample_result=None,
+):
+    """建立人工樣本結果審核預覽；預設不載入 sample result。"""
+    evaluation = evaluate_manual_sample_result(
+        sample_result,
+        acceptance_contract,
+    )
+    gate_checks = {
+        "acceptance_contract_ready": bool(
+            acceptance_contract
+            and acceptance_contract.get("contract_ready")
+        ),
+        "sample_review_is_pure_function": True,
+        "external_network_blocked_in_review": True,
+        "database_write_still_blocked": not bool(
+            getattr(runtime_status, "database_write_allowed", False)
+        ),
+        "scheduler_detached": not bool(
+            getattr(runtime_status, "scheduler_attached", False)
+        ),
+    }
+    blocked_reasons = [
+        key for key, passed in gate_checks.items()
+        if not passed
+    ]
+    if not evaluation["sample_result_loaded"]:
+        blocked_reasons.append("sample_result_not_loaded")
+    if not evaluation["ready_for_candidate_preview"]:
+        blocked_reasons.append("candidate_preview_not_ready")
+    blocked_reasons.append("candidate_import_still_blocked_until_operator_approval")
+
+    return {
+        "mode": "manual_sample_review_preview",
+        "contract_ready": bool(gate_checks["acceptance_contract_ready"]),
+        "sample_result_loaded": evaluation["sample_result_loaded"],
+        "sample_result_reviewed": evaluation["sample_result_reviewed"],
+        "sample_result_accepted": evaluation["sample_result_accepted"],
+        "ready_for_candidate_preview": evaluation["ready_for_candidate_preview"],
+        "candidate_import_allowed": False,
+        "external_network_executed": False,
+        "database_connection_opened": False,
+        "database_session_created": False,
+        "database_write_executed": False,
+        "database_commit_executed": False,
+        "scheduler_attached": False,
+        "writes_executed": False,
+        "would_write_database": False,
+        "gate_checks": gate_checks,
+        "blocked_reasons": blocked_reasons,
+        "review_result": evaluation["review_result"],
+        "review_checks": evaluation["review_checks"],
+        "review_findings": evaluation["review_findings"],
+        "candidate_summary": evaluation["candidate_summary"],
+        "operator_next_actions": [
+            {
+                "key": "load_single_sample_result_manually",
+                "label": "由操作員提供單一平台 sample result JSON，再用純函式審核",
+                "write_status": "blocked",
+            },
+            {
+                "key": "open_candidate_preview_after_pass",
+                "label": "審核通過後只開候選活動預覽，仍不得寫入 market_campaigns",
+                "write_status": "blocked",
+            },
+            {
+                "key": "revise_adapter_source_after_reject",
+                "label": "審核未通過時調整 adapter source 或暫停該平台",
+                "write_status": "blocked",
+            },
+        ],
+        "safe_boundaries": [
+            "do_not_fetch_external_pages_from_review_api",
+            "do_not_store_sample_result_from_review_preview",
+            "do_not_import_candidates_from_review_preview",
+            "do_not_write_market_tables_from_review_preview",
+            "do_not_attach_scheduler_from_review_preview",
+            "do_not_touch_momo_db_lifecycle",
+        ],
+    }

services/market_intel/service.py

@@ -36,6 +36,9 @@ from services.market_intel.manual_sample_plan import (
 from services.market_intel.manual_sample_acceptance import (
     build_manual_sample_acceptance_preview,
 )
+from services.market_intel.manual_sample_review import (
+    build_manual_sample_review_preview,
+)
 from services.market_intel.migration_blueprint import build_migration_blueprint
 from services.market_intel.migration_catalog_review import (
     build_migration_catalog_review_preview,
@@ -98,7 +101,7 @@ class MarketIntelRuntimeStatus:
 class MarketIntelService:
     """市場情報入口服務，先集中 feature gate 與安全狀態。"""
 
-    phase = "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    phase = "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
 
     def get_runtime_status(self) -> MarketIntelRuntimeStatus:
         return MarketIntelRuntimeStatus(
@@ -447,6 +450,16 @@ class MarketIntelService:
         acceptance["phase"] = self.phase
         return acceptance
 
+    def build_manual_sample_review(self, sample_result=None):
+        """回報人工 sample result 審核預覽；預設不載入結果、不寫 DB。"""
+        review = build_manual_sample_review_preview(
+            runtime_status=self.get_runtime_status(),
+            acceptance_contract=self.build_manual_sample_acceptance(),
+            sample_result=sample_result,
+        )
+        review["phase"] = self.phase
+        return review
+
     def build_match_review_plan(self):
         """回報商品比對審核計畫；不建立 queue、不自動確認。"""
         schema_smoke = self.build_schema_smoke()

templates/market_intel/disabled.html

@@ -522,6 +522,24 @@
         </div>
     </div>
 
+    <div class="market-intel-panel" data-market-intel-sample-review>
+        <div class="market-intel-preview-head">
+            <div>
+                <p class="market-intel-muted momo-mono mb-1">MANUAL SAMPLE / REVIEW</p>
+                <h2 class="market-intel-preview-title">樣本結果審核預覽</h2>
+            </div>
+            <button class="market-intel-icon-button" type="button" title="重新整理樣本結果審核預覽" data-market-intel-sample-review-refresh>
+                <i class="fas fa-rotate-right" aria-hidden="true"></i>
+            </button>
+        </div>
+        <div class="market-intel-preview-meta" data-market-intel-sample-review-meta>
+            <span class="market-intel-pill">loading</span>
+        </div>
+        <div data-market-intel-sample-review-body>
+            <div class="market-intel-empty">讀取樣本結果審核預覽中...</div>
+        </div>
+    </div>
+
     <div class="market-intel-panel" data-market-intel-scheduler>
         <div class="market-intel-preview-head">
             <div>
@@ -773,6 +791,7 @@
         const mcpFetchGateRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-mcp-fetch-gate]');
         const manualSampleRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-manual-sample]');
         const sampleAcceptanceRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-acceptance]');
+        const sampleReviewRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-review]');
         const schedulerRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-scheduler]');
         const matchReviewRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-match-review]');
         const opportunityRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-opportunity]');
@@ -786,7 +805,7 @@
         const liveInventoryRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-live-inventory]');
         const approvalRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-approval]');
         const deployRoot = document.querySelector('[data-market-intel-deploy]');
-        if (!root && !writerRoot && !cliRoot && !dbProbeRoot && !seedDiffRoot && !legacyBridgeRoot && !mcpReadinessRoot && !mcpPreflightRoot && !mcpActivationRoot && !mcpFetchGateRoot && !manualSampleRoot && !sampleAcceptanceRoot && !schedulerRoot && !matchReviewRoot && !opportunityRoot && !opportunityScoringRoot && !opportunityEvidenceRoot && !opportunityAlertRoot && !migrationRoot && !migrationDrillRoot && !catalogReviewRoot && !liveSmokeRoot && !liveInventoryRoot && !approvalRoot && !deployRoot) return;
+        if (!root && !writerRoot && !cliRoot && !dbProbeRoot && !seedDiffRoot && !legacyBridgeRoot && !mcpReadinessRoot && !mcpPreflightRoot && !mcpActivationRoot && !mcpFetchGateRoot && !manualSampleRoot && !sampleAcceptanceRoot && !sampleReviewRoot && !schedulerRoot && !matchReviewRoot && !opportunityRoot && !opportunityScoringRoot && !opportunityEvidenceRoot && !opportunityAlertRoot && !migrationRoot && !migrationDrillRoot && !catalogReviewRoot && !liveSmokeRoot && !liveInventoryRoot && !approvalRoot && !deployRoot) return;
 
         const meta = root ? root.querySelector('[data-market-intel-preview-meta]') : null;
         const body = root ? root.querySelector('[data-market-intel-preview-body]') : null;
@@ -836,6 +855,10 @@
         const sampleAcceptanceBody = sampleAcceptanceRoot ? sampleAcceptanceRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-acceptance-body]') : null;
         const sampleAcceptanceRefresh = sampleAcceptanceRoot ? sampleAcceptanceRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-acceptance-refresh]') : null;
         const sampleAcceptanceEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel.market_intel_manual_sample_acceptance') }}";
+        const sampleReviewMeta = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-review-meta]') : null;
+        const sampleReviewBody = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-review-body]') : null;
+        const sampleReviewRefresh = sampleReviewRoot ? sampleReviewRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-sample-review-refresh]') : null;
+        const sampleReviewEndpoint = "{{ url_for('market_intel.market_intel_manual_sample_review') }}";
         const schedulerMeta = schedulerRoot ? schedulerRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-scheduler-meta]') : null;
         const schedulerBody = schedulerRoot ? schedulerRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-scheduler-body]') : null;
         const schedulerRefresh = schedulerRoot ? schedulerRoot.querySelector('[data-market-intel-scheduler-refresh]') : null;
@@ -1809,6 +1832,99 @@
             }
         };
 
+        const renderSampleReviewMeta = data => {
+            sampleReviewMeta.innerHTML = [
+                `mode=${data.mode || 'unknown'}`,
+                `loaded=${data.sample_result_loaded ? 'yes' : 'no'}`,
+                `reviewed=${data.sample_result_reviewed ? 'yes' : 'no'}`,
+                `result=${data.review_result || 'planned'}`,
+                `import=${data.candidate_import_allowed ? 'open' : 'blocked'}`
+            ].map(item => `<span class="market-intel-pill">${escapeHtml(item)}</span>`).join('');
+        };
+
+        const renderSampleReviewBody = data => {
+            const blockers = (data.blocked_reasons || []).join(' / ');
+            const checks = data.review_checks || [];
+            const findings = data.review_findings || [];
+            const candidates = data.candidate_summary || {};
+            const actions = data.operator_next_actions || [];
+            const boundaries = data.safe_boundaries || [];
+            const renderCheck = item => `
+                <div class="market-intel-check">
+                    <div>
+                        <strong>${escapeHtml(item.key || 'check')}</strong>
+                        <small>${escapeHtml(item.label || '')}</small>
+                    </div>
+                    <span>${escapeHtml(item.status || 'planned').toUpperCase()}</span>
+                </div>
+            `;
+            const renderNamedItem = (item, status) => {
+                const normalized = typeof item === 'string' ? { key: item, label: item } : (item || {});
+                return `
+                    <div class="market-intel-check">
+                        <div>
+                            <strong>${escapeHtml(normalized.key || normalized.label || 'item')}</strong>
+                            <small>${escapeHtml(normalized.label || normalized.key || '')}</small>
+                        </div>
+                        <span>${escapeHtml(normalized.severity || normalized.write_status || status || 'blocked').toUpperCase()}</span>
+                    </div>
+                `;
+            };
+            sampleReviewBody.innerHTML = `
+                <div class="market-intel-empty mb-3">此卡只用純函式審核人工 sample result；目前預設不載入結果、不抓外站、不存檔、不寫 DB、不建立候選活動。${blockers ? `阻擋：${escapeHtml(blockers)}` : ''}</div>
+                <div class="market-intel-empty mb-3">candidate_count=${escapeHtml(candidates.candidate_count || 0)} / accepted=${escapeHtml(candidates.accepted_candidate_count || 0)} / bands=${escapeHtml((candidates.accepted_candidate_bands || []).join('/'))}</div>
+                <div class="market-intel-deploy-grid">
+                    <div data-market-intel-sample-review-checks>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">REVIEW CHECKS</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            checks.length
+                                ? checks.map(renderCheck).join('')
+                                : '<div class="market-intel-empty">尚未載入 sample result，審核檢查維持 planned。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div data-market-intel-sample-review-findings>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">FINDINGS</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            findings.length
+                                ? findings.map(item => renderNamedItem(item, 'block')).join('')
+                                : '<div class="market-intel-empty">目前沒有審核發現；尚未載入結果時代表未評估。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div data-market-intel-sample-review-actions>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">NEXT ACTIONS</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            actions.length
+                                ? actions.map(item => renderNamedItem(item, item.write_status || 'blocked')).join('')
+                                : '<div class="market-intel-empty">尚未提供下一步。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                    <div data-market-intel-sample-review-boundaries>
+                        <p class="market-intel-deploy-section-title">BOUNDARIES</p>
+                        <div class="market-intel-check-list">${
+                            boundaries.length
+                                ? boundaries.map(item => renderNamedItem(String(item), 'required')).join('')
+                                : '<div class="market-intel-empty">尚未提供安全邊界。</div>'
+                        }</div>
+                    </div>
+                </div>
+            `;
+        };
+
+        const loadSampleReview = async () => {
+            if (!sampleReviewMeta || !sampleReviewBody) return;
+            sampleReviewBody.innerHTML = '<div class="market-intel-empty">讀取樣本結果審核預覽中...</div>';
+            try {
+                const response = await fetch(sampleReviewEndpoint, { credentials: 'same-origin' });
+                if (!response.ok) throw new Error(`HTTP ${response.status}`);
+                const data = await response.json();
+                renderSampleReviewMeta(data);
+                renderSampleReviewBody(data);
+            } catch (error) {
+                sampleReviewMeta.innerHTML = '<span class="market-intel-pill">error</span>';
+                sampleReviewBody.innerHTML = `<div class="market-intel-empty">樣本結果審核預覽讀取失敗：${escapeHtml(error.message)}</div>`;
+            }
+        };
+
         const renderSchedulerMeta = data => {
             schedulerMeta.innerHTML = [
                 `mode=${data.mode || 'unknown'}`,
@@ -3297,6 +3413,9 @@
         if (sampleAcceptanceRefresh) {
             sampleAcceptanceRefresh.addEventListener('click', loadSampleAcceptance);
         }
+        if (sampleReviewRefresh) {
+            sampleReviewRefresh.addEventListener('click', loadSampleReview);
+        }
         if (schedulerRefresh) {
             schedulerRefresh.addEventListener('click', loadScheduler);
         }
@@ -3348,6 +3467,7 @@
         loadMcpFetchGate();
         loadManualSample();
         loadSampleAcceptance();
+        loadSampleReview();
         loadScheduler();
         loadMatchReview();
         loadOpportunity();

tests/test_market_intel_skeleton.py

@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ from services.market_intel.mcp_deploy_preflight import build_mcp_deploy_prefligh
 from services.market_intel.mcp_fetch_gate import build_mcp_fetch_gate_preview
 from services.market_intel.mcp_readiness import build_mcp_readiness_plan
 from services.market_intel.live_db_inventory import build_live_db_inventory_preview
+from services.market_intel.manual_sample_review import evaluate_manual_sample_result
 from services.market_intel.platform_seed_db_diff import build_platform_seed_db_diff_plan
 from services.market_intel.schema_db_probe import build_schema_db_probe_plan
 
@@ -510,6 +511,11 @@ def test_market_intel_preview_template_uses_safe_fetch_false_endpoint():
     assert "data-market-intel-sample-acceptance-checks" in template
     assert "data-market-intel-sample-acceptance-fields" in template
     assert "data-market-intel-sample-acceptance-rules" in template
+    assert "data-market-intel-sample-review" in template
+    assert "data-market-intel-sample-review-checks" in template
+    assert "data-market-intel-sample-review-findings" in template
+    assert "data-market-intel-sample-review-actions" in template
+    assert "data-market-intel-sample-review-boundaries" in template
     assert "data-market-intel-approval" in template
     assert "data-market-intel-approval-gates" in template
     assert "data-market-intel-deploy" in template
@@ -527,6 +533,7 @@ def test_market_intel_preview_template_uses_safe_fetch_false_endpoint():
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_mcp_fetch_gate" in template
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_manual_sample_plan" in template
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_manual_sample_acceptance" in template
+    assert "market_intel.market_intel_manual_sample_review" in template
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_scheduler_plan" in template
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_match_review_plan" in template
     assert "market_intel.market_intel_opportunity_plan" in template
@@ -562,7 +569,7 @@ def test_legacy_source_bridge_default_is_planned_only():
     bridge = MarketIntelService().build_legacy_source_bridge()
 
     assert bridge["mode"] == "legacy_source_bridge_planned"
-    assert bridge["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert bridge["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert bridge["execute_requested"] is False
     assert bridge["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert bridge["database_connection_opened"] is False
@@ -720,7 +727,7 @@ def test_mcp_tool_contract_preview_is_read_only_and_whitelisted():
     contract = MarketIntelService().build_mcp_tool_contract()
 
     assert contract["mode"] == "mcp_tool_contract_preview"
-    assert contract["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert contract["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert contract["caller"] == "market_intel"
     assert contract["contract_ready"] is True
     assert contract["blocked_reasons"] == []
@@ -853,7 +860,7 @@ def test_mcp_activation_runbook_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "mcp_activation_runbook_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["deployment_actions_executed"] is False
     assert data["docker_command_executed"] is False
     assert data["ssh_command_executed"] is False
@@ -866,7 +873,7 @@ def test_mcp_fetch_gate_default_blocks_external_fetch():
     gate = MarketIntelService().build_mcp_fetch_gate(fetch_requested=True)
 
     assert gate["mode"] == "mcp_fetch_gate_planned"
-    assert gate["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert gate["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert gate["fetch_requested"] is True
     assert gate["manual_fetch_gate_open"] is False
     assert gate["network_request_allowed"] is False
@@ -936,7 +943,7 @@ def test_mcp_fetch_gate_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "mcp_fetch_gate_planned"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["fetch_requested"] is False
     assert data["network_request_allowed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -948,7 +955,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_plan_preview_blocks_fetch_and_write():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "manual_sample_fetch_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert plan["ready_for_manual_sample_fetch"] is False
     assert plan["sample_fetch_executed"] is False
     assert plan["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -996,7 +1003,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_fetch_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["sample_fetch_executed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
     assert data["database_write_executed"] is False
@@ -1007,7 +1014,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_acceptance_preview_blocks_candidate_import():
     acceptance = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_acceptance()
 
     assert acceptance["mode"] == "manual_sample_acceptance_preview"
-    assert acceptance["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert acceptance["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert acceptance["contract_ready"] is True
     assert acceptance["sample_result_loaded"] is False
     assert acceptance["sample_result_accepted"] is False
@@ -1049,7 +1056,7 @@ def test_manual_sample_acceptance_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_acceptance_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["sample_result_loaded"] is False
     assert data["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -1057,11 +1064,135 @@ def test_manual_sample_acceptance_route_is_preview_only():
     assert data["scheduler_attached"] is False
 
 
+def test_manual_sample_review_preview_is_planned_until_result_loaded():
+    review = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_review()
+
+    assert review["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_preview"
+    assert review["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
+    assert review["contract_ready"] is True
+    assert review["sample_result_loaded"] is False
+    assert review["sample_result_reviewed"] is False
+    assert review["sample_result_accepted"] is False
+    assert review["ready_for_candidate_preview"] is False
+    assert review["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
+    assert review["external_network_executed"] is False
+    assert review["database_connection_opened"] is False
+    assert review["database_session_created"] is False
+    assert review["database_write_executed"] is False
+    assert review["database_commit_executed"] is False
+    assert review["scheduler_attached"] is False
+    assert review["writes_executed"] is False
+    assert review["would_write_database"] is False
+    assert review["review_result"] == "planned_no_sample_result"
+    assert "sample_result_not_loaded" in review["blocked_reasons"]
+    assert "candidate_import_still_blocked_until_operator_approval" in review["blocked_reasons"]
+    assert "do_not_fetch_external_pages_from_review_api" in review["safe_boundaries"]
+    assert "do_not_write_market_tables_from_review_preview" in review["safe_boundaries"]
+
+
+def test_manual_sample_review_evaluator_accepts_good_result_without_import():
+    acceptance = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_acceptance()
+    sample_result = {
+        "batch_id": "sample-batch-1",
+        "platform_code": "pchome",
+        "source_key": "homepage",
+        "source_url": "https://24h.pchome.com.tw/",
+        "status": "fetched",
+        "status_code": 200,
+        "content_length": 1200,
+        "page_hash": "a" * 64,
+        "title": "PChome 活動",
+        "diagnostics": {
+            "link_count": 3,
+            "same_host_link_count": 2,
+            "campaign_link_candidates": [
+                {
+                    "confidence_band": "high",
+                    "score": 82,
+                    "url": "https://24h.pchome.com.tw/activity/sample",
+                    "text": "品牌活動",
+                },
+            ],
+        },
+    }
+
+    result = evaluate_manual_sample_result(sample_result, acceptance)
+
+    assert result["sample_result_loaded"] is True
+    assert result["sample_result_reviewed"] is True
+    assert result["sample_result_accepted"] is True
+    assert result["ready_for_candidate_preview"] is True
+    assert result["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
+    assert result["review_result"] == "accepted_for_candidate_preview"
+    assert all(check["passed"] for check in result["review_checks"])
+    assert result["review_findings"] == []
+    assert result["candidate_summary"]["candidate_count"] == 1
+    assert result["candidate_summary"]["accepted_candidate_count"] == 1
+
+
+def test_manual_sample_review_evaluator_rejects_bad_result():
+    acceptance = MarketIntelService().build_manual_sample_acceptance()
+    sample_result = {
+        "batch_id": "sample-batch-2",
+        "platform_code": "shopee",
+        "source_key": "mall",
+        "source_url": "https://shopee.tw/mall",
+        "status": "blocked",
+        "status_code": 403,
+        "content_length": 120,
+        "page_hash": "short",
+        "title": "",
+        "diagnostics": {
+            "link_count": 0,
+            "same_host_link_count": 0,
+            "campaign_link_candidates": [],
+        },
+    }
+
+    result = evaluate_manual_sample_result(sample_result, acceptance)
+
+    assert result["sample_result_loaded"] is True
+    assert result["sample_result_reviewed"] is True
+    assert result["sample_result_accepted"] is False
+    assert result["ready_for_candidate_preview"] is False
+    assert result["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
+    assert result["review_result"] == "rejected_sample_result"
+    assert {item["key"] for item in result["review_findings"]} >= {
+        "http_status_ok",
+        "content_has_body",
+        "candidate_quality_reviewed",
+    }
+
+
+def test_manual_sample_review_route_is_preview_only():
+    from routes.market_intel_routes import market_intel_bp
+
+    app = Flask(__name__)
+    app.secret_key = "test-secret"
+    app.register_blueprint(market_intel_bp)
+    client = app.test_client()
+    with client.session_transaction() as session:
+        session["logged_in"] = True
+
+    response = client.get("/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review")
+    data = response.get_json()
+
+    assert response.status_code == 200
+    assert data["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_preview"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
+    assert data["sample_result_loaded"] is False
+    assert data["sample_result_reviewed"] is False
+    assert data["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
+    assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
+    assert data["database_write_executed"] is False
+    assert data["scheduler_attached"] is False
+
+
 def test_scheduler_plan_preview_blocks_job_attachment():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_scheduler_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "scheduler_attach_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert plan["ready_to_attach_scheduler"] is False
     assert plan["scheduler_attached"] is False
     assert plan["scheduler_registration_executed"] is False
@@ -1099,7 +1230,7 @@ def test_scheduler_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "scheduler_attach_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["scheduler_registration_executed"] is False
     assert data["crawler_job_started"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -1110,7 +1241,7 @@ def test_match_review_plan_preview_blocks_auto_confirm():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_match_review_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "match_review_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert plan["ready_for_review_queue"] is False
     assert plan["review_queue_created"] is False
     assert plan["auto_match_executed"] is False
@@ -1146,7 +1277,7 @@ def test_match_review_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "match_review_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["review_queue_created"] is False
     assert data["auto_confirm_executed"] is False
     assert data["external_network_executed"] is False
@@ -1157,7 +1288,7 @@ def test_opportunity_plan_preview_blocks_alerts_and_ai_summary():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert plan["ready_for_opportunity_queue"] is False
     assert plan["opportunity_queue_created"] is False
     assert plan["threat_alert_dispatched"] is False
@@ -1198,7 +1329,7 @@ def test_opportunity_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["opportunity_queue_created"] is False
     assert data["threat_alert_dispatched"] is False
     assert data["ai_summary_generated"] is False
@@ -1209,7 +1340,7 @@ def test_opportunity_scoring_plan_preview_blocks_scoring_and_alerts():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_scoring_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_scoring_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert plan["ready_for_scoring_job"] is False
     assert plan["scoring_job_created"] is False
     assert plan["score_calculation_executed"] is False
@@ -1257,7 +1388,7 @@ def test_opportunity_scoring_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_scoring_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["scoring_job_created"] is False
     assert data["score_calculation_executed"] is False
     assert data["sample_scores_generated"] is False
@@ -1269,7 +1400,7 @@ def test_opportunity_evidence_plan_preview_blocks_queries_and_alerts():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_evidence_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_evidence_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert plan["ready_for_evidence_bundle"] is False
     assert plan["evidence_bundle_created"] is False
     assert plan["evidence_query_executed"] is False
@@ -1315,7 +1446,7 @@ def test_opportunity_evidence_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_evidence_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["evidence_bundle_created"] is False
     assert data["evidence_query_executed"] is False
     assert data["sample_evidence_generated"] is False
@@ -1328,7 +1459,7 @@ def test_opportunity_alert_plan_preview_blocks_dispatch_and_llm_calls():
     plan = MarketIntelService().build_opportunity_alert_plan()
 
     assert plan["mode"] == "opportunity_alert_plan_preview"
-    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert plan["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert plan["ready_for_alert_candidates"] is False
     assert plan["alert_candidate_created"] is False
     assert plan["alert_queue_created"] is False
@@ -1413,7 +1544,7 @@ def test_opportunity_alert_plan_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "opportunity_alert_plan_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["alert_candidate_created"] is False
     assert data["alert_queue_created"] is False
     assert data["review_queue_created"] is False
@@ -1491,7 +1622,7 @@ def test_mcp_deploy_preflight_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "mcp_external_deploy_preflight_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["deployment_actions_executed"] is False
     assert data["docker_command_executed"] is False
     assert data["ssh_command_executed"] is False
@@ -1506,7 +1637,7 @@ def test_mcp_readiness_default_is_planned_only(monkeypatch):
     readiness = MarketIntelService().build_mcp_readiness()
 
     assert readiness["mode"] == "mcp_readiness_planned"
-    assert readiness["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert readiness["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert readiness["execute_requested"] is False
     assert readiness["router_enabled"] is False
     assert readiness["external_mcp_complete"] is False
@@ -1896,6 +2027,7 @@ def test_deployment_readiness_reports_app_only_release_gate():
     assert readiness["checks"]["scheduler_plan_preview_safe"] is True
     assert readiness["checks"]["manual_sample_plan_preview_safe"] is True
     assert readiness["checks"]["manual_sample_acceptance_preview_safe"] is True
+    assert readiness["checks"]["manual_sample_review_preview_safe"] is True
     assert readiness["checks"]["match_review_plan_preview_safe"] is True
     assert readiness["checks"]["opportunity_plan_preview_safe"] is True
     assert readiness["checks"]["opportunity_scoring_plan_preview_safe"] is True
@@ -1928,6 +2060,7 @@ def test_deployment_readiness_reports_app_only_release_gate():
     assert "/api/market_intel/scheduler_plan" in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
     assert "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_plan" in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
     assert "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_acceptance" in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
+    assert "/api/market_intel/manual_sample_review" in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
     assert "/api/market_intel/match_review_plan" in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
     assert "/api/market_intel/opportunity_plan" in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
     assert "/api/market_intel/opportunity_scoring_plan" in readiness["production_smoke_targets"]
@@ -1985,6 +2118,13 @@ def test_deployment_readiness_reports_app_only_release_gate():
     assert readiness["manual_sample_acceptance"]["external_network_executed"] is False
     assert readiness["manual_sample_acceptance"]["database_write_executed"] is False
     assert readiness["manual_sample_acceptance"]["scheduler_attached"] is False
+    assert readiness["manual_sample_review"]["mode"] == "manual_sample_review_preview"
+    assert readiness["manual_sample_review"]["sample_result_loaded"] is False
+    assert readiness["manual_sample_review"]["sample_result_reviewed"] is False
+    assert readiness["manual_sample_review"]["candidate_import_allowed"] is False
+    assert readiness["manual_sample_review"]["external_network_executed"] is False
+    assert readiness["manual_sample_review"]["database_write_executed"] is False
+    assert readiness["manual_sample_review"]["scheduler_attached"] is False
     assert readiness["scheduler_plan"]["scheduler_registration_executed"] is False
     assert readiness["scheduler_plan"]["crawler_job_started"] is False
     assert readiness["scheduler_plan"]["database_write_executed"] is False
@@ -2089,7 +2229,7 @@ def test_migration_apply_drill_planned_is_safe_and_manual_only():
     drill = MarketIntelService().build_migration_apply_drill()
 
     assert drill["mode"] == "migration_apply_drill_preview"
-    assert drill["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert drill["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert drill["execute_requested"] is False
     assert drill["schema_state"] == "planned_no_db_probe"
     assert drill["drill_ready_for_operator_review"] is True
@@ -2204,7 +2344,7 @@ def test_migration_apply_drill_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "migration_apply_drill_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["migration_executed"] is False
     assert data["rollback_executed"] is False
@@ -2216,7 +2356,7 @@ def test_migration_catalog_review_planned_is_safe_and_diagnostic():
     review = MarketIntelService().build_migration_catalog_review()
 
     assert review["mode"] == "migration_catalog_review_preview"
-    assert review["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert review["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert review["execute_requested"] is False
     assert review["catalog_state"] == "planned_no_probe"
     assert review["seed_state"] == "planned_no_probe"
@@ -2331,7 +2471,7 @@ def test_migration_catalog_review_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "migration_catalog_review_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["catalog_state"] == "planned_no_probe"
     assert data["migration_executed"] is False
@@ -2344,7 +2484,7 @@ def test_migration_live_smoke_planned_is_preview_only():
     smoke = MarketIntelService().build_migration_live_smoke()
 
     assert smoke["mode"] == "migration_live_smoke_preview"
-    assert smoke["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert smoke["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert smoke["execute_requested"] is False
     assert smoke["smoke_result"] == "planned_no_execution"
     assert smoke["live_smoke_passed"] is False
@@ -2406,7 +2546,7 @@ def test_migration_live_smoke_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "migration_live_smoke_preview"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["smoke_result"] == "planned_no_execution"
     assert data["migration_executed"] is False
@@ -2419,7 +2559,7 @@ def test_live_db_inventory_planned_is_preview_only():
     inventory = MarketIntelService().build_live_db_inventory()
 
     assert inventory["mode"] == "live_db_inventory_planned"
-    assert inventory["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert inventory["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert inventory["execute_requested"] is False
     assert inventory["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert inventory["database_connection_opened"] is False
@@ -2563,7 +2703,7 @@ def test_live_db_inventory_route_is_preview_only():
 
     assert response.status_code == 200
     assert data["mode"] == "live_db_inventory_planned"
-    assert data["phase"] == "phase_48_manual_sample_acceptance_contract"
+    assert data["phase"] == "phase_49_manual_sample_result_review"
     assert data["execute_requested"] is False
     assert data["read_only_query_executed"] is False
     assert data["database_write_executed"] is False